The Time Capsule: Modified crops: Which side is right?

While buying garden seeds this spring I was reminded of what may be a growing and insidious global problem. On the other hand, it may be nothing at all. Experts on each side of the issue are so far apart there seems to be no middle ground.

Jere Gettle, who deals in heirloom vegetable seeds, told me it is becoming more difficult each year to find seeds that have not been contaminated by genetically engineered (GE) or modified crops. He is among many, including some independent scientists, who are convinced GE corn, beans, soy and canola are doing harm to people, animals and other plants. According to Colorado State University Extension, everything from cereal to syrup to vegetable oil, an estimated 60-70 percent of processed food in grocery stores, contains at least one GE component.  

Monsanto and mega-agriculture insist GE food is no different from a health standpoint than non-GE. 

I don’t know which side is right. I do, however, feel uneasy about dining on something that has been genetically modified in a manner that causes it to either tolerate or create poison.   

Big chemical interests say we need GE to feed the world. Opponents say that’s rubbish, yields are not greatly increased and what we’re doing is poisoning the world. They reference studies alleged to show gruesome things happening to animals fed GE grain, to sheep dying after grazing GE fields, to deformed pigs, liver damage, to an increase in human illness and allergies since the inception and widespread use of GE. The April issue of Mother Earth News references a long-term French study that reportedly found significant health problems in rats fed genetically engineered corn.   

Chemical companies offer convincing studies refuting these charges. They also oppose efforts by those who want to have food labeled as being GE. The current federal administration is on the side of GE food, although the first family won’t eat it.   

Who is telling the truth? I don’t put a great deal of trust in Monsanto or any other entity or individual with a financial stake in the matter.  Neither am I inclined to accept without question the opinion of environmentalists, lobbyists, or career politicians.   

One day, I suppose, the issue will be resolved. We’ll know whether GE foods are doing damage or not; although—like eggs and coconut oil—the pendulum may swing both ways.

Regardless, there should be labeling requirements. Consumers have a right to know. 

Special interest groups fight this, saying it’s too difficult, too expensive, and there’s no reason for it. The same was said about the requirement for a label to disclose a product’s country of origin. 

Opponents of labeling say those concerned about GE can buy organically labeled products. True, but organic covers multiple aspects some are not concerned about. They don’t mind chemical fertilizer, don’t insist bad bugs be dealt with organically, but they but do want to know which grocery items contain GE components. 

I don’t think that’s an unreasonable request.   

Roy Marshall is a local historian and columnist for the Red Oak Express. He can be contacted at news@redoakexpress.com.

The Red Oak Express

222 E. Coolbaugh St.
P.O. Box 377
Red Oak, IA 51566
Phone: 712-623-2566 Fax: 712-623-2568

Comment Here