Voters deserve to know where hotelmotel tax is going
Would you vote for a tax increase when you didn’t know where the money was going?
That question has divided Red Oak’s city council regarding the proposed hotel/motel tax.
The Council voted 4-1 to form a committee that not only will promote the tax before the November election, but will also make recommendations to the Council on how it should be spent after soliciting public input.
Fred Pilecki voted against forming the committee, as he believes announcing where the money will be spent could cause some to vote against the tax simply because they don’t like the designated organization(s).
Mayor Bill Billings shares Pilecki’s concerns, stating after the tax passes, the Council will have plenty of time to decide how to spend it before any money is available.
No one else on the Council seems to agree with that approach and quite frankly, neither do I.
I don’t like the “just vote for the tax and trust us to spend it how you’d want” approach. Maybe I’m too much of a skeptic or too untrusting, or maybe I’ve just seen too many rogue councils go in a completely different direction than their constituents want for me to write that blank check.
In fact, I would argue the Council isn’t going nearly far enough to ensure the wants and desires of the public are going to be protected in terms of how this money is spent.
State law requires 50 percent of the income generated be spent on tourism and recreational related activities while the other 50 percent can be spent however the Council sees fit.
Now, the Council has voted to form a task force that will conduct public meetings, maybe print a few surveys and will solicit a lot of opinions on how that other 50 percent should be divided.
Then the committee will take their recommendations to the Council that X percent should go this group and Y percent should go that group. This committee may even continue to serve in that capacity after the tax passes and present future proposals on how to spend the revenue generated.
Here’s my concern: Larry Barnett cautioned his fellow council members about forming a committee and not giving them any power to do anything; unfortunately, I think that’s exactly what could happen.
As the ballot currently reads, all the Council has to do is follow the state law regarding the tax revenues. As long as 50 percent is spent on tourism and park maintenance, which could theoretically include routine maintenance such as mowing, they can spend the other 50 percent however they want.
In fact, according to the ballot, they can abolish this committee whenever they want, or simply never adhere to any of their recommendations.
Ballot language for a tax proposal can be a tricky animal. A few years ago, voters overwhelmingly throughout the county approved implementing a local sales tax. In Red Oak, the ballot language was explicit in stating the funds had to be used for new capital improvements and projects, paving the way for the purchase of fire trucks, police cars and computers at the schools.
That specific ballot language prohibited using the money on routine maintenance and upkeep of exisiting facilities.
Because of that explicit language, voters could rest assured the money would be spent as promised, only on new projects, regardless of what a governing body wanted to do.
Therein lies the comfort and security a lot of voters want before heading to the polls.
Unfortunately, as it reads now, the current hotel/motel tax provides none of that comfort, security or confidence.
The current Council can promise to listen to the public and adhere to the task force’s recommendations and I don’t doubt they wouldn’t be sincere in that pledge.
But what’s to stop a council in three years, or five or 10 from abolishing the committee and using the other 50 percent of the hotel taxes to give city employees a pay raise, or on a fancy lawnmower, or on a program offering free pictures with a kangaroo?
I know that sounds ridiculous, but that’s the point. If there isn’t ballot language preventing it, a future Council could do whatever it wants with the money completely contrary to what the public envisioned when it supported it.
That’s the reason the Local Option Sales Tax passed so easily. Voters knew where the money would go and had 100 percent confidence it wouldn’t be used for general upkeep.
I found it somewhat ironic when Mayor Billings commented he didn’t want to see the tax money being spent on copy machines, brochures or stacks of paper. However, if there isn’t specific language on the ballot directing those dollars, the Council could very well vote to buy a half dozen copiers if they so desired.
Pilecki, meanwhile, seemingly took issue with community members who said their support of the tax would be contingent upon where the money was spent.
I don’t understand why that is such a bad thing. In fact, it sounds much more fiscally responsible than simply passing a tax with no direction as to where it would go.
No, I’m inclined to agree with Barnett. People want to know how the government, whether its Congress or the City Council, is going to spend their tax dollars.
And I would hope the Council strongly considers adding more explicit ballot language to provide voters the confidence they need to make sure that money is spent as they intend in the future.
Gregory Orear is the General Manager/Editor of the Red Oak Express. He can be contacted at publisher@redoakexpress.com
