Guest Editorial | Rod Goodemote

I am a 1983 graduate of Stanton, will be a resident again in 2012, and have followed the school sharing situation for over a year.  All of the discussion so far has led to more questions than answers.  One question that has been raised is…Would we keep the high school?  As far as I can tell, that question is irrelevant until the larger question is addressed which is…Should we share schools at all?

What effort was put forth to brainstorm other ideas so that we would not be put into a position of having to share?  I have put forth the ideas of starting an International student program which I have participated in for the last three years in Florida, which increases our local schools population, increases school’s finances, improves competition and academics, and has benefited my family both financially and culturally.  I also put forth the idea of offering open-enrollment scholarships to families that would like to open enroll but are unable due to finances.  

I realize that in a public school there may be hurdles to jump through to implement these programs, but I do not think the tasks are insurmountable.  My point with stating these ideas is that when you open up brainstorming to the public, other ideas are found and can be refined.  

The only ideas I saw presented to the community were share/merge with this school, share/merge with that school, and/or pay higher taxes.

The most important question that needs to be addressed by sharing with any other school is… Will academics be improved?  I cannot see how bussing students 10 or 11 miles improves academics.  The only argument I can see that anyone would have is that it may give the ability to offer some “specialty classes” to some students due to the increase in class-size; however, for the majority nothing would be improved.

So, what would happen if schools shared?  Siblings would be separated, parents would sometimes be driving in two different directions, and both parents and teachers would be giving up some control of the education process.
Another important question is …. does it make economic sense to share?  

The economic incentive here is that the government will give the school more money if we share.  I question whether this is a wise use of taxpayer’s money.  

Why would the state do this?  The state wants to provide the money because sharing is the gateway to school merger.  

Even with school merging, I don’t think much, if any, money would be saved.  The true economics of the whole scenario is a lot of parent’s money would be wasted driving up and down the road.

Other important questions to address are as follows:  Where do the teachers stand on the issue?  Where do retired teachers stand?  If sharing is such a wonderful idea, then where is the school leadership’s document that outlines how and why it makes economic and academic sense?  

We have a very well written feasibility study that says other schools are a great match.  

I fully understand some argue a conflict of interest with that study. However, I don’t understand why a new document outlining sharing benefits has not been created.

It has been stated several times that Stanton has three or four years before they will be at the point where they will likely be forced to share or merge. Let’s spend that three or four years making steady improvements in the student population and in academics so the state will see an upward, improving trend.  

If after we have given our best shot, then we will play the cards we are dealt.  

I would like to end by commending and thanking the Stanton school leadership and teachers by stating they have done an outstanding job of providing academic excellence while maintaining expenses as low as possible.

— Rod Goodemote

The Red Oak Express

222 E. Coolbaugh St.
P.O. Box 377
Red Oak, IA 51566
Phone: 712-623-2566 Fax: 712-623-2568

Comment Here