Local schools react differently to below-average ACT scores
RED OAK — Each fall, dozens of seniors from southwest Iowa schools get together to be tortured for a couple hours on a Saturday morning.
The instrument used to torment them: The ACT.
“It’s a bear of a test,” Red Oak High School Counselor John Brabec said of the college entrance exam. “They take a Saturday morning to essentially be tortured.”
The nationally-administered test has become a staple for acceptance into most four-year colleges and is used as a barometer for many local, state and national scholarships.
“Whether they get into the college of choice or the the program they want can be based on their score, as well as the scholarships they get,” Brabec said. “Students today understand the importance of that score.”
Local Schools Scores
Red Oak has lagged behind the state averages in the college entrance exam for several years.
In 2011, the 47 students who took the test averaged a 21 composite score, compared to a state average of 22.3. In the last five years, the closest Red Oak came to the state average was in 2009 with a score of 21.5, nearly a full point below the mark of 22.4.
“Our scores aren’t good enough, but we are taking steps to improve it,” High School Principal Jed Sherman said. “It isn’t a quick fix, because we didn’t get here overnight.”
The numbers are similar in Villisca, where composite scores of 20.1, 19.6, 21.5 and 20.7 have been anywhere from .9-2.6 points below the state average.
They did have the highest average score in the county in 2007 with a 23.7, compared to the state mark of 22.3.
Superintendent Willie Stone said they don’t necessarily focus on ACT scores as a measuring stick for school success.
“Our board places a main focus on improving instruction for all students,” Stone said. “Knowing that focus, the result of having better instruction and our students learning more is students test scores going up. But our main goal is making sure we are improving instruction in our classroom.”
Stone also points out at 53 percent, 2011’s graduating seniors had the lowest rate taking the test. The percent of seniors taking the test was as high as 75 percent in 2009 and 72 percent in 2010.
“Not all of those kids are going to four-year colleges,” he said. “Some of it is the result of scholarship offerings that ask for ACT scores.”
Nearly 80 percent of Stanton seniors took the ACT in 2011, and the school recorded its lowest average in more than five years at 20.0. It had exceeded the state average the previous year (22.4-22.2), and was close the year before that (22.1-22.4).
When discussing the more than 2-point drop in average scores from 2010 to 2011, Counselor Sheila Mainquist argued its not necessarily a reflection of a change at the school.
“Truthfully, it is the students in the class, it has nothing to do with academic preparation,” she said. “It is the individuals. I pulled out those tests (from 2011) and looked at the kids, and I think that was a pretty accurate assessment of those kids.”
She believes tests like the ACT aren’t always the best way to assess a student’s academic abilities.
“You have to look at it with a very open mind when you look at things. Numbers don’t always mean what they say,” she said. “My opinion is not every student is a great test taker. It is very hard for every student to perform well on that. We all have different skills, strengths and weaknesses, and not every kid’s strength is a pencil and bubble test.”
And with as many as 88 percent of the senior class taking the test (2009), Mainquist said the scores aren’t always indicative of those pursuing a 4-year degree.
“Half of them probably didn’t go to a 4-year college. They weren’t even kids who needed to take it,” she said. “A lot of our kids take it because they think they should, because they want to know how they measure up. And that is fine.”
Improving Scores
Mainquist and Brabec both recommend students, especially college bound ones, to take the test first in the spring of their junior year, and then again in the fall of the senior year.
“It doesn’t hurt to take it more than once, because colleges will always take the higher score,” Brabec said. “If you do more preparation or have taken certain courses, your score can go up.”
Mainquist’s own daughter took the test four times, but she said she was lucky to get her son to take it twice.
“When kids take it, they are lucky if they raise one or two points,” she said. “You rarely get a kid who raises it more than 2-3 points.”
There are practice tests, study guides and computer programs available to help students improve their scores.
But none of the schools have formal ACT preparation courses. At least, not yet.
Board Directive
At this year’s goal setting meeting, Red Oak school board clearly identified improving ACT scores as something to work on for the next couple years.
While an exact number has not been set, Sherman realizes they want to see the school’s average closer to that of the state’s.
“My vision is to raise the ACT scores through my teacher’s work and the resources we have available online,” Sherman said.
Those online resources include the ACT Online Prep program, which will include all juniors and seniors.
Students in those classes will take the online ACT preparation test in order to establish a baseline score from which the school will try to improve.
But more importantly, it will also provide them the tools to do it, as they will be able to see what questions students answer incorrectly. More precisely, they will also get to see which incorrect answer the students were more likely to choose. From there, they will be able to better customize classroom instruction to address those weaker areas.
“We know the student got a 25 on the ACT or a 15 or whatever, but we don’t know why,” Brabec said. “This allows us to pick at the data and utilize it in a meaningful way.”
Sherman believes that kind of analysis will be an invaluable teaching tool.
“If everyone is missing a certain mechanical part of grammar, then we will know we need to work on that area specifically,” he said.
Eventually, Sherman can envision the school incorporating the ACT Online Prep program into a preparation course.
But for now, his goal is simple.
“Improving ACT scores was one of the goals of the school board, and its one of the goals of this school,” he said.
