Surprises abound in city election, court decisions
When asked what I thought would happen before last week’s municipal election, I’d offer my opinion with the qualifier I have a bad history of predicting elections, and this one was as unpredictable as any.
This one didn’t fail to live up to those standards, not only in the race for mayor, but for City Council as well.
With Bill Billings receiving more votes than all other four mayor candidates combined, and Scott Keith defeating longtime Council member Roger Waggener in the Ward 1 race, Red Oak voters sent an obvious message of displeasure with the status quo.
Including the mayor, the six faces of city government will look very different in January 2012 than it did in January 2011, as only council members Tom Pratt and Kevin Gregg remain one year later.
I cite two actions, or lack thereof, of the current council that contributed to this sentiment.
First, the Council lost a lot of credibility with the public with the handling of the lawsuit filed against City Administrator Brad Wright and the City by former animal control officer Christine Morrison.
After the Council found out about the lawsuit through a phone call from me seeking comment on it, their reaction, at least publicly, was disappointingly indifferent.
Instead of justifiably expressing outrage and reprimanding those responsible for excluding them from vital information about the city, they used the same cloak of secrecy to keep the public in the dark that had just been used on them.
Secondly, for right or wrong, I believe the Council was somewhat held responsible for the mayor’s decision to not allow citizen comment until relenting earlier this year and allowing up to two minutes per person at the beginning of the first meeting of the month.
While the Council couldn’t have prevented the mayor from barring public comment, they certainly could have solicited it on their own or publicly challenged the mayor the practice.
On both counts, they chose not to.
Also, it didn’t help Larry Brandstetter’s cause when he essentially stated the only change he would make to the exisiting policy would be to allow comments at the beginning of each meeting, albeit under similar time limits.
With that air of discontent, Billings took full advantage, and pushed just the right buttons with the electorate. Billings is an eloquent speaker, and was aware of enough to capitalize on that discontent and channel that anger and frustration into votes.
One reasonable criticism of Billings and his campaign is he simply told people what they wanted to hear.
That may very well be true, but it’s only a valid criticism if he fails to follow through on what he told them.
If he doesn’t, another mayor’s election will roll around in two years, and a new batch of candidates, along with possibly some of this year’s, will challenge Billings and potentially capitalize on the same era of frustration and discontent that got Billings elected in the first place.
*****
On an equally surprising, albeit much more serious note, Karli Jo Brown received two, 10-year prison sentences for her role in the deaths of two children in a 2010 car wreck.
Brown was driving the vehicle that collided head-on with a car carrying Maiki and Alex Todd, killing the 5- and 4-year-olds instantly.
Brown was speeding and passing in a no passing zone, and depending on who you believe, either had just texted her boyfriend or was in the process of itas the wreck occurred.
Regardless, she received the maximum sentence of 10-years. However, the judge did show some leniency by assigning the terms to run at the same time rather than consecutively.
In this same column, I had predicted based on her lack of a criminal record, and the absence of malicious intent, she would received a suspended jail sentence or simply be placed on probation.
Clearly, my ability to predict elections is on par with predicting judge’s decisions.
Watching the anguish and pain the boys’ family went through in the brief time I saw them in the courtroom was gut wrenching.
While I pray I never have to experience the kind of pain associated with the loss of a child, I wish there were some way to bottle the emotions in that courtroom so others could experience it and learn from it.
I don’t know if anything good will ever come from this, but the boys’ mother, Nina McNeese, is visiting local high schools to warn students about the perils of driving while distracted and the treacherous conseequences their actions can result in.
It is certainly a lesson worth telling and hopefully one that will be shared with students throughout Southest Iowa.
Gregory Orear is the General Manager/Editor of the Red Oak Express. He can be contacted at publisher@redoakexpress.com
