Noble intentions can go awry
When I was a young lad, a friend of mine and I would pedal our bicycles to the local drug store to buy the staples of our youth: baseball and football cards for $.35 a pack, a replacement whiffle ball for the one we hit into a gutter or simply destroyed, and packages of big league chew to chomp on while we played said whiffle ball game.
One day though, I wanted to buy something extra nice for my mother’s birthday, so I scraped together all my loose change and headed to the drug store with about $5 burning a hole in my pocket.
But this drug store was more mom and pop than a national chain, and as such, its size and inventory was somewhat limited.
Not to an 8-year-old boy with $5 in his pocket. I could buy anything, or so I thought.
Soon, my eyes landed on what I thought was an exquisite serving platter. I knew it wasn’t gold, but it was painted in a similar color, and the flashiness of it caught my eye, along with the imprinted design in its bowl.
Perfect I thought. Mom likes serving food in fancy dishes when company arrives, so she’ll love this.
I make my purchase, take it home, wrap it up to the best of my ability and give it to my mom.
That’s when I learn the beautiful platter I purchased was actually an ashtray.
Oops.
And to make matters worse, my mom had just quit smoking a few months earlier.
Double oops.
Naturally, being the great mother she is, my mom smiled gracefully and acted like I gave her exactly what I intended to…a priceless present she would treasure forever.
My intentions were noble…but my execution stunk.
Whether its little boys or even grown up boys, men can be notorious for this type of behavior. We don’t intend on looking like a heel when we buy our wives a vacuum cleaner for Christmas. We think a new tool in their workshop will be a welcome addition, like a new power saw in our own garage.
Oops.
But these noble intentions gone awry are most dangerous when they manifest in the legislature.
Missouri’s House and Senate recently passed by a unanimous vote a law that restricts teacher’s ability to communicate with students via social network sites, such as Facebook.
As astounding as a unanimous vote in both houses may be, even more telling is how quickly the law was ruled unconstitutional by a district judge.
The argument for the prohibition of teachers “friending” students and vice-versa is it could lead to inappropriate conduct. The argument against the ban is this is how the current generation communicates, and as such, teachers need to be able to use it as well.
Banning teachers from being computer friends with their students in order to avoid inappropriate conduct is a noble goal.
But trying to reach this goal through banning Facebook relationships isn’t going to achieve it. If a teacher desires that sort of relationship, they will seek it out through more traditional means if necessary.
Quite frankly, I view it as the equivalent of banning teachers from calling students on their cell phones 10 years ago, or their home phones 20 years ago, or maybe talking to them at the corner drug store 30 years ago.
Gregory Orear is the general manager/editor of the Red Oak Express and can be reached at publisher@redoakexpress.com.
