Ernst criticizes veto closing Red Oak’s workforce office

DES MOINES — In 2010, Council Bluffs’ Iowa Workforce Development Office staff served 6,312 resource room clients, posted 2,700 jobs, and registered 3,802 job seekers. With an office budget of $1,971,899, those 12,814 services cost $153.89 each.

In Red Oak’s comparatively Spartan-like office with a $68,138 budget, 2,219 similar services occurred.

That’s a cost of $30.70 each, or more than five times less than 60 miles away in Council Bluffs.

When Gov. Terry Branstad used a line item veto to remove one-year funding for 33 field offices, he unilaterally eliminated a lifeline for rural Iowa job seekers, one local Senator believes.

“Every time I went in the office, there was someone getting help on a resume, working on a mock interview, or something,” Joni Ernst (R-Red Oak) said last week about Red Oak’s office. “There’s a lot of wonderful things going on there that require one-on-one interaction. We are going to lose that extra effort in the rural communities where it may be needed most.”

In 2010, Red Oak was grappling with one of the state’s highest unemployment rates, and Ernst believes Branstad should have considered keeping those heavily used offices open.

“This was an easy solution to essentially close all rural offices,” she said.

Inside the Numbers

While Red Oak’s average of $30.70 per service is the extreme in terms of cost-effectiveness, other rural field offices reflect similar trends.
Glenwood, Clarinda and Osceola features rates ranging from $73-$77 a service.

The most expensive offices in the state are typically the larger, regional ones, including Dubuque ($153), Waterloo ($146), Sioux City ($145), Cedar Rapids ($144) and Des Moines ($129).

Region 14’s office, located in Creston, operates at a $257.80 per service rate. Red Oak and Osceola comprise the rest of Region 14.
However, field offices located closer to urban areas also carry higher per service rates.

In Decorah, located in Region 1 with Dubuque, the average cost per service is $135. Ames checks in at $79, while Iowa City, which is in the same region as Sioux City, provided services at an average cost of $110 each.

Incidentally, Decorah completed 19 fewer services (2,200-2,219) than Red Oak’s office, with a budget four times higher ($298,000-$68,318).
What’s Next

Any hope of keeping Red Oak’s office opened ended with the legislative session and Branstad’s veto.

Ernst said the bipartisan piece of legislation that would have kept the offices opened provided funding for one-year, which is why the governor vetoed it.

“House Republicans and Senate Democrats came up with a plan to keep the offices open one more year,” she said. “Unfortunately, the governor felt very strongly they should be closed because it was one-time funding to be used to keep them open.”

Ernst said a special session was considered to override Branstad’s veto, but that the Republican caucus couldn’t justify a costly special session for just one issue.

“If we were to go through a costly special session, we would to work on more than just the Iowa Workforce,” she said, referring to property tax relief and job creation bills that weren’t completed. “We would end up speading a lot more money … and we don’t want to do that during a recession.”

As a result, the workforce office will be closed by the end of the year. Computer stations are expected to be installed at the public library and Southwest Community College to provide some of the support clients currently receive.

“I don’t think we should rely on volunteers at our library to provide job assistance,” Ernst said. “Then people are going to be upset when they can’t get help from the librarian on how to write a resume.”

The Red Oak Express

222 E. Coolbaugh St.
P.O. Box 377
Red Oak, IA 51566
Phone: 712-623-2566 Fax: 712-623-2568

Comment Here