Baby Mommas
RED OAK — The good news across the state and nation is teen pregnancy rates are decreasing.
The bad news is that's not true here in Montgomery County.
Defying the state and national trends, teen pregnancy remains in double digits in Montgomery County, topping out at 10.3 percent in 2009, down from 11.6 percent in 2008.
According to figures from the Iowa Department of Public Health, over the course of the last five years, the rate was as high as 12 percent in 2005, and as low as 8 percent in 2007. However, in every year but 2007, the rate was above the state average, which fluctuated from 8.5-9 percent.
And according to Sue Drake, Montgomery County Public Health Administrator, there is no reason to believe that number is going to go anywhere but up. She works with many of the teenagers through the Women Infants and Children nutrition program.
We have several 16-year-olds pregnant in Red Oak, and even a couple 14 and 15 year-olds, which we never had before,” Drake said. “I don't know why the numbers are going up. Everybody is asking why is there so many?”
Red Oak High School Counselor John Brabec doesn't have an easy answer.
“It is such an individualized thing, I don't know if there is a specific reason,” he said. “I think young people know what causes it and how to prevent it, and for some reason, are choosing not to. Some of it is 'it will always happen to somebody else, not me, I'm invulnerable.'”
Drake is more worried about the health of the newborns.
“Teen pregnancy does correspond to low birth weights,” she said. “A teen's body isn't prepared to carry a baby to its full weight … so they end up delivering it early, and smaller.”
The Iowa Department of Public Health also reports:
— Most teen births (76 percent) occurred to women 18-19 years old, with 23 percent to women aged 15-17;
— About four percent of women ages 15-19 give birth each year in Montgomery County, representing about 10 percent of all births in the county;
— In 2008, the teen birth rate was 32.1 per 1,000, compared to an overall birth rate in the county of 12 per 1,000;
— Montgomery County ranks 33rd in teen birth rate among all Iowa counties;
Jennifer Horner, an educator with Planned Parenthood in Red Oak, said 50 percent of all pregnancies are unplanned, and about 90 percent of teen pregnancies are.
While teen pregnancies cost the nation an estimated $9 billion in 2005, Horner believes it is in society's best interest to reduce the number of unwanted pregnancies.
“This is a public health issue,” she said. “It affects all of us, not just the couple involved in the pregnancy.”
Horner is in the first year of teaching a “research based” Human Growth and Development course that she said provides a “comprehensive” approach to sexual education.
“I think now, we are doing pretty well here in Red Oak. It's great to teach research-based curriculum,” she said.
She said the 16-week course does include discussions on abstinence.
“It (abstinence) is discussed and highlighted, but its not the only thing discussed because research shows comprehensive discussions are most affective,” Horner said. “If you really understand what comprehensive education is, there really aren't a “both sides” issue. That is what comprehensive is. It covers everything.”
Brabec said the abstinence portion of any sexual education course is important.
“I do think abstinence needs to be an emphasis … it is the best way and only way to be truly protected,” he said. “Contraceptives don't protect against the emotional baggage that goes around with it. When a relation becomes sexual in nature, it becomes much more complex emotionally, and no contraceptive in the world is going to help with that.”
Horner also taught the previous sexual education courses, which lasted just two days, focusing on sexually transmitted infections and birth control, while ignoring the relationship aspects Brabec mentioned.
“Those are one-shot wonder classes. Who knows how affective they are,” she said. “This is better for the kids because it helps them to better handle the decisions based on information.”
In addition to the high school courses, Horner is teaching puberty classes to fourth and fifth graders, and a self-esteem course in the sixth, seventh and eighth grades called “Draw the Line. Respect the line.”
She does emphasize though the school should not be taking the lead role in sex education.
Parents should the primary sex educators of their children. Schools should only be a back up and reinforcement to what the parents are teaching,” she said. “We don't teach values, except for the universal values of respect and responsibility, and teaching values is … entirely the responsibility of the parents. So parents, talk to your kids about your values. Don't assume they now what your values are.”
