Red Oak and its experiences in Southwest League baseball
Don Hicks, who has played, coached and watched a lot of baseball, called to ask if I was aware of a professional league formed in Red Oak in 1903. I was not. He provided material compiled by Tim Rask for The Iowa Baseball Project. From this and a little additional research emerges a sports story so whacky it could only be true.
Local newspapers took a serious interest when the Southwest Iowa League was officially formed during a March 25, 1903 meeting at Red Oak’s Hotel Johnson. Planning, though, had gone on for months. Teams would be made up of salaried players with a 42-game pennant race. A number of Iowa towns, plus two from Nebraska, expressed interest in competing. But at the Hotel Johnson meeting only four; Red Oak, Atlantic, Clarinda and Shenandoah, were awarded franchises. This alignment featured the natural Clarinda-Shenandoah rivalry. Atlantic and Red Oak didn’t like each other much, and the sentiment grew as the summer progressed.
Season openers were in mid-May. Clarinda took a pair from Shenandoah. Atlantic beat Red Oak, but the second game was rained out. Rain continued. More games were postponed. With Red Oak’s diamond all but under water, the second game of the series was played a week late at Red Oak’s golf course. Baseball on the back nine, although well-drained, did not work out.
Rain persisted. On May 28, Red Oak lost a wet one in extra innings to Shenandoah, with the only score coming when a fair ball mired in a mud hole.
There were other problems, one of which was umpires. Some accounts say they were grossly incompetent. Others professed they were simply crooked. Fans tended to be no better. Rowdy and obnoxious, they taunted, cursed, gambled openly, and fights were not uncommon. Ladies and other mild-manner spectators wanting to enjoy a nice game in a pleasant setting stayed away.
With the season only a month the league was in trouble. Revenue was not covering expenses. League officials, over Shenandoah’s objection, decided to expand and include Creston and Osceola. Expansion meant starting over, and in late June a new 60-game schedule was unveiled. Fan response was initially good, with some games drawing 1,000 or more. There were, however, ongoing problems. Betting in the stands continued unchecked. Umpires were not satisfying. Spikes flew and rivalries got personal. Games were protested and there was no instant replay.
Shenandoah, which hadn’t done the league many favors, won 9, lost 9, then quit. The team would play no more. The season continued with an awkward 5-team format. Clarinda took first place early, challenged by Atlantic and Creston. July turned to August and Creston faltered. Atlantic lost seven straight. Clarinda seemed in control until Atlantic rattled the opposition by hiring a professional team from Ogden, Utah. The ringers beat Red Oak, then trounced Clarinda. By mid-August Atlantic, starting several of the Utah pros, was closing on Clarinda. Creston stayed in contention with Osceola and Red Oak far behind.
On Aug. 28, with 14 games remaining, the boys from Red Oak failed to show up for a two-game series in Atlantic. When contacted they said they were done?would not finish the season. This crisis was more than the league could overcome and the second season, like the first, ended prematurely.
Controversy continued. Newspaper standings showed Clarinda in first place, but Atlantic claimed the title. Five contested games were at issue. These included three Atlantic losses protested because of allegedly bad calls. Atlantic insisted these defeats were wins. The other two were the games Red Oak did not play. Atlantic put them in the win column. It was pointed out that Red Oak had quit before the games, and a forfeit over a team not then in the league should not count. Everyone but Atlantic resented a string of victories taken by imports from Utah, which was legal but not endearing.
Our Red Oak Express declared Clarinda had earned the pennant, as did the Clarinda newspaper. The league president, however, lived in Atlantic. This may not have been a factor, but when Atlantic was officially declared winner of all five disputed games, and awarded the pennant, many thought otherwise. But at least it was, blessedly, over.
Roy Marshall is a local historian and columnist for the Red Oak Express. He can be contacted at news@redoakexpress.com.
