Watching the wheels of justice

In my 15-plus year career as a journalist, I’ve covered a handful of trials, and remember them all explicitly.

There was the 15-year-old murder case of a young woman, where both suspects walked due to a lack of evidence.

There was the 60-year-old woman accused of shooting her husband with a high-powered rifle, as he sat fishing on a riverbank. They found her guilty, but just of manslaughter, and because of possible domestic abuse, she was out of prison in five years.

I remember the trial of a young man who got super-drunk, led police on a high-speed chase throughout town, and eventually slammed into an officer’s car. The 10-year police vet, who was less than a block from his home, died from his injuries a few months later, and the drunk driver received a 7-year sentence for involuntary manslaughter.

And there was the mayor accused of burning down her bar. She received five years for arson, and just lost another round of appeals.

Despite the different charges, and outcomes, one thing that always held true was how interesting I found these trials. Watching the interaction between lawyers, judges, witnesses and defendants was intriguing at the least.

Anyone who has spent a minute in any of those aforementioned trials knows exactly the source of the phrase courtroom drama.

For that reason alone, if you have the chance to attend a significant court case, whether as a witness or juror, I would urge you to do so. Watching this country’s wheels of justice in motion is amazing in and of itself. But to experience firsthand the tension in the courtroom as a verdict is being read is unlike any other.

With that said, I couldn’t be any more disappointed with a recent United States Supreme Court decision to prevent the broadcast of the Proposition 8 trial in California.

For those who don’t know, Proposition 8, as approved by California voters, bans same-sex marriage. Now, that ban is being challenged in a federal court.

The court’s judge had made provisions for the potentially landmark civil rights trial to be broadcast nationwide, but the Supreme Court stepped in at the last minute, and banned it by a 5-4 vote.

There reasoning is supporters of the ban fear witnesses who testify will be harassed to and from the courtroom.

Applying that reasoning, the court may want to consider banning vehicles, because of the potential of intoxicated individuals getting behind the wheel.

Technology in our society is evolving at a break-neck pace. With that, the public will have more and more access to their government, but decisions such as this will only prevent that access.

Regardless of how you feel about same-sex marriage, this was a golden opportunity for opponents and supporters to be able to watch a civil discussion and debate into one of the most controversial civil rights issues facing our nation. This was the opportunity to watch history in the making.

Instead, the Supreme Court has prevented that. And no matter how you view it, pun intended, that’s simply wrong.

Gregory Orear is the General Manager/Editor of the Red Oak Express. He can be emailed at publisher@redoakexpress.com.

The Red Oak Express

222 E. Coolbaugh St.
P.O. Box 377
Red Oak, IA 51566
Phone: 712-623-2566 Fax: 712-623-2568

Comment Here