Jail committee obstacles
Montgomery County’s jail committee met with another consultant last week hired to study the feasibility of constructing a new jail.
A significant portion of the meeting was dedicated to the question of funding and what it will take to convince the general public to support a bond issue and ensuing property tax increase.
Generally speaking, going for a property tax increase in Iowa seems a little unfair in some regards, as it only taxes landowners. Everyone who lives in an apartment will have no reason to vote against the proposal, as they don’t have to pay taxes on their home.
This is compounded by the fact that Iowa doesn’t levy a property tax on vehicles, boats or other personal property, leaving even more of the cost burden on the homeowner.
And in a rural county like this one where agriculture is so important, farmers have an additional expense placed on them. Unlike myself, or the guy who goes to work at Parker-Hanifan, or Mensa, the farmer is also going to have to pay extra taxes on his source of income, his farm.
That’s a large segment of the population that will need a lot of convincing to take money from their pockets to pay for a new jail.
What’s unfortunate though is the committee really doesn’t have many options in terms of alternative funding methods.
In the last town I worked, sales taxes were the favored mechanism used by taxing entities. In the four plus years I worked there, I saw sales taxes passed for purchases of a fire truck, construction of a four-lane highway and a bypass, improvements to the streets, and assorted “capital improvement projects” which include a biking trail and skate park.
But in Iowa, where the state sales tax is higher, the local option sales tax is capped out much lower, at just one percent. And Montgomery County is already at that maximum, with most of those funds going to secondary roads.
To the voters, a sales tax is a much more appealing option, as it spreads the burden more evenly upon everyone, property owner and non-property owner alike. Also, there is the attractive aspect that people coming through town will buy items and help pay for your fire truck, new highway, or jail.
But not with a property tax. The out-of-towner might get arrested and have to utilize the jail’s accommodations, but he will never be taxed for it like the farmer with 100 acres and a couple dozen head of cattle.
If this consulting firm does succeeds where so many of their predecessors failed and actually get a proposal to the public to vote on, they will have a very difficult task ahead of them.
Jails aren’t like a new school, fire truck or highway. It doesn’t make most people’s lives easier, or give them a warm-fuzzy feeling. And with the struggling economy and the negative feelings already surrounding this project, this committee has three significant obstacles to overcome.
I’m not going to call it an impossible task, because the one thing the committee and the project does have going for it is a legitimate need. The current jail is in a horrible condition, and something has to be done.
But as an old judge once told me many, many years ago, it’s very difficult to educate the electorate.
And that’s exactly what the jail committee is going to have to do.
Gregory Orear is the General Manager/Editor of the Red Oak Express. He can be emailed at publisher@redoakexpress.com.
