The sad tale of Arch Breeding
The holiday season seventy-five years ago was, for some Red Oakers, not the happiest. That autumn the town had been the site of a chilling murder, followed by a speedy trial that ended before Thanksgiving. A Red Oak man spent Christmas on death row in Fort Madison, waiting to be hanged.
Arch Breeding was 19, Florence Grace Hull 17, when they married. Their daughter, Bernice, was born in 1916. The family lived for a time in Nebraska, then in 1919 moved to Red Oak, settling into a small home at 100 Nuckols.
Arch was a heavy drinker at a time when the sale of liquor was generally illegal. He worked at various jobs, including several stints at the Murphy Calendar Company, but his binges contributed to a spotty employment record. While drinking he was sometimes abusive. In the early 1930s police were regularly called to his home to intervene in domestic disputes. Florence threatened divorce in the summer of 1934. Arch promised to change his life, to stop drinking, and the couple reconciled.
By fall, however, Breeding had resumed his former ways. Finally, in early October, his wife followed through with her divorce threat. Arch Breeding brooded for a day or two, then on the evening of Friday, October 5, he entered Samuelson’s Cigar Store where he worked as a part-time janitor. Breeding knew the owner kept a revolver in a desk in the back room, and when he left the gun was in his pocket. At shortly after 10 p.m. he arrived at the home on Nuckols, stepped onto the porch and knocked on the door. Brief words were exchanged, then Breeding emptied the revolver. One bullet struck his wife in the forehead, and she fell dead.
Breeding fled south toward the calendar plants, then to the railroad tracks. He walked west for several hours before deciding to give himself up.
There was no question of guilt. His daughter had witnessed the shooting. Neighbors saw Breeding fleeing the scene. The suspect confessed, telling the press he deserved the death sentence. But was the crime premeditated? County Attorney Lester Orsborn had no doubt and sought the death penalty.
Breeding’s court-appointed attorney waived trial by jury. Judge H.O. Mantz heard witnesses, including those who offered evidence that Breeding had stolen the revolver for the purpose of killing his wife.
On the morning of October 26, 1934, the defendant was escorted into the courtroom by Sheriff Conkel and Bailiff Bernard Peterson. Judge Mantz asked Breeding if he had anything to say. He did not. Judge Mantz read from a statement declaring the crime to have been willful and premeditated. “Therefore,” he said, “it is my order that you be taken to the state penitentiary in Fort Madison and be held there until October 29, 1935, when you shall be executed. . . ”
The only man ever sentenced to death in Montgomery County awaited his fate for a year. But legal technicalities and an effort by local citizens to spare his life resulted in an eleventh hour commutation. Breeding was eventually released and return to Red Oak. He died in 1971 and is buried next to his wife.
Roy Marshall is a local historian. E-mail him at news@redoakexpress.com
