Charles Van Doren 50 years ago
This week our column goes back 50 years, to that unpleasant time when we learned Charles Van Doren was a fraud and television more committed to ratings than integrity.
Most everyone knows the story, either by being there when events played out or through the 1994 movie, ‘Quiz Show.’ Van Doren, touted as being a college professor (which he wasn’t), became a contestant on one of television’s most popular game shows. Over a period of several weeks the nation watched as Van Doren, peering from a supposedly sound-proof booth, demonstrated a nearly incomprehensible knowledge. He seemed to know everything; the Latin name of obscure plants, the inventor of the flush toilet, the gestation period of a water buffalo. He won a small fortune, made the cover of Time, then went to work for NBC doing news. He filled in for Dave Garroway and was awarded a regular slot on the Today show.
When allegations of the fix surfaced Van Doren told the public, his lawyer, and swore to a grand jury that everything had been legitimate. But when others started singing he decided to come clean.
Van Doren, now 84, refused for decades to talk about the incident, even turning down $100,000 to be a consultant for the ‘Quiz Show’ movie. But recently he wrote a lengthy article which provides details not previously made public.
Van Doren tells us he went on the show to beat the seemingly unbeatable Herb Stempel. As some of you may recall, Herb came across as a nerd. His suits too tight, bad haircut, sweat too much. But his IQ was clocked at 170 and he beat all comers. Ratings fell. The sponsors wanted him gone. A producer had a talk with the youthful, good-looking Van Doren. The match would be a long one, tension building as the contestants tied week after week, but Van Doren would eventually win because he was given all the questions, all the answers. He was rehearsed, instructed on matters of timing and mannerisms. He became a celebrity. Stempel, who looked worse as the shows progressed because he was supposed to, was told to lose. He argued, then relented. Fifty million viewers were pulling for him to go, and so he did.
But after a few weeks of Van Doren the ratings again went stagnant, and Vivienne Nearing was chosen to topple him. On that fateful night the contestants were asked to name the kings of Norway, Denmark, Sweden, Jordan, Iraq and Belgium. Van Doren tells us he knew them all, but he’d been instructed to muff Belgium.
Two years later, in 1959, he confessed. Had Van Doren stuck to his denial, kept his job with NBC, he might have gone on to become a news anchor. There are reasons, I think, not to trust anchors.
