New Inman renovation option

The Red Oak School Board has moved closer to determining a final design plan for Inman Elementary renovations.
At a special work session April 30, the board discussed updated renovation plans with Chandler Green, representing Alley Poyner Macchietto Architecture. Among the upgrades needed is a roof replacement, totaling $1,388,200 Green was also able to share with the board the cost estimate from Engineering Technologies Inc. of Omaha for replacing Inman’s HVAC system.
“It’s a three-unit system. There’s two units on the roof and one in the west mechanical. They’ve come up with kind of two different options and are trying to study those a little bit more. Going the chilled water replacement, which is option two in their assessment, is anywhere from about $1.5 to $1.8 million. They also have identified a couple other additional items that are optional or would need to be done with that larger construction project. Another item they identified is replacing the VAV boxes, which are needed but not necessarily right now, so you wouldn’t necessarily have to spend those costs,” Green said.
Also under ETI’s plan was changing all of the lighting within the building, upgrading it from fluorescent, which could be done and completed with a Mid-American Energy rebate, but could be done at any time. However, one item of importance was the fire alarm and security. Green advised the board if it does any type of addition to the building, they would be required to upgrade the fire alarm system at a cost of around $100,000-$150,000, and the security system upgrades would be around $30,000.  The rough estimate to do all the HVAC and other work was around $2 million.
With those cost estimates, Green shared an updated renovation plan that reduced the scope of work to lower the construction costs.
“This option kind of gets you a little bit of everything. It gets you the north commons addition, so you can still fit 160 students in there. It reduces the footprint, taking away the additional storage in there and really streamlining what happens in that north commons. The other portion is really reducing the work that’s done in the admin space. So there’s some give and take where just because we’re taking out square footage, there’s still a lot of footings, foundations, et cetera, that need to be done, so it’s not a direct square foot cost, But in talking with Boyd Jones, we think that this option could be viable, where we leave a lot more in place and really minimally add on. It leaves your secure entry or your existing vestibule but creates a secure entry within the existing openings that you have that are windows today, making those doors to come into a new reception area with a workroom towards the back and the south space becomes your office space and conference zone. This particular version leaves the nurse’s station and some of this plumbing in place,” advised Green. “Outside, the glazing comes more to the private side of the building and faces the north and then we bring the windows down a little bit more, and reduces the costs of the project from more than $4 million to $2.1 to $2.4 million.”
Green confirmed the reduced project still included  new security entries and doors. Members of the board were still interested in adding additional storage space that was included in the $4.1 million design so it could be included if the bids on the project were low enough.
Green was asked how close the estimated costs would be to the actual figures. Green stated based on conversations with Boyd Jones and ETI, that the costs were pretty accurate. Green also told the board portions of the HVAC project couldn’t wait and that according to the assessment, the district was about four to five years past the recommended life of the units. One unit in particular that had major issues with some of the coiling units. Superintendent Ron Lorenz said the district did have one option to reduce the total costs of the HVAC upgrades.
“We have gotten some feedback from, I don’t know, a service individual who is of the opinion that we could squeeze five years, maybe seven years out of those systems. Now you could have a coil that could fail. You could have a condenser that would fail, and you might have to put $5,000 or $10,000 here. And there’s really no way to foresee that. That could happen in any system we have. But that’s a lot different than putting $2 million in. Now, ultimately, we’re going to have to do that, but I necessarily think we need to do that tomorrow,” said Lorenz.
Board member Scott Bruce also spoke during the meeting and looked at some of the building’s needs with the district’s maintenance staff.
“We’ve had the roof looked at and have come to the conclusion that maybe we could buy five to seven years with regular repair and maintenance,” said Bruce.
The board also discussed whether or not the plans to start the project in the fall were possible. Green informed the board that it was not, as questions were still being raised on the design and which option to choose. Lorenz added that since it was a work session, the board couldn’t act on any plans anyway, and with all that in mind, the earliest the project could begin would be in the spring of next year.
The board had initially planned to discuss timelines and a strategy for community engagement opportunities, but as a final design plan had yet to be approved, the discussions were tabled until the project was closer to a determined scope.
The board also discussed the district’s finances with Matt Gillaspie, senior vice president of public finance at Piper Jaffray & Co. in Des Moines.
Gillaspie advised the board that in the spring or summer of 2029, based on sales tax revenue bonds, the district could spend up to $12.4 million on new projects. That would require a public hearing and there would be a 14-day window where citizens could petition the board to stop. If petitioned, the board could call for an election for permission to issue sales tax bonds, and the election would have to happen in November.
Gillaspie also advised the board that the district’s existing voted PPEL, which is $1.34 the maximum amount that a school can have, expires in fiscal year 2030, and Red Oak’s requires an income surtax, so the district will have to levy at least a 1% income surtax, because that’s what the ballot dictated. Once renewed, the district doesn’t require any public hearings or special permission to borrow against it.
Another funding source was general obligation bonds, which would require a 60% approval from the public at election. if the district wanted to borrow from a general obligation bond in the spring or summer of 2029, it would have to have that election successfully in November of 2028 or before. That type of election can only happen one time a year and only in November, and the district could borrow up to $16 million towards projects. With sales tax revenue bonds and PPEL, the total borrowing would max out at around $32 million.
As for money on hand, Lorenz said the district had $3.5 million in PPEL funding and $3.7 million in SAVE dollars. Lorenz added the district has been looking to do the project without issuing bonds or referendums. Gillaspie said there was no industry standard set on how much the district should hold back, but said around $700,000 to $1 million was optimal, but sometimes boards went as low as $500,000.
No other action was taken by the board.

The Red Oak Express

222 E. Coolbaugh St.
P.O. Box 377
Red Oak, IA 51566
Phone: 712-623-2566 Fax: 712-623-2568

Comment Here