Jury acquits Norris of first-degree election misconduct

After a slow beginning, the trial of Joey Norris ended with a not-guilty verdict.
Norris was on trial on a charge of first-degree election misconduct, a Class D Felony. The charge stems from a Nov. 5, 2024 incident in which Norris was removed from the absentee election board by Montgomery County Auditor Jill Ozuna.
The entire first day of the trial on Oct. 6 was spent seating the 12 member jury and two alternates, before opening statements took place on Oct. 7. Assistant Attorney General Joshua Duden, prosecuting the case for the Iowa Attorney General’s Office, claimed that Norris was an election official and willfully performed his duties and responsibilities as an election official in such a way as to hinder or disregard the object of the law in violation of Iowa Code.
Duden told the jury that five of the board’s members had worked efficiently towards their duties, but one hindered or slowed down the efficiency of the process despite the looming deadline, and that individual was Joey Norris.
“Joseph Norris was one of those six members, and again he was new serving for the first time. Despite most others having done this job for years, he started to impede the process in a number of ways, or stop it from being able to move forward in an efficient way. That included times where he interrupted the count again and again, where he tried to pass information regarding rejected ballots, or the status of those votes, to his mother, Jan Norris, who was a political observer in the room, despite the auditor telling him no, and that there was not to be communication between the observers and the board,” said Duden.
Duden also advised the jury that Norris stopped the scanning of the ballots to ask or even demand that the auditor fill in the oval on a ballot that was not his own, and when the auditor refused, he continued to argue and ultimately said that there was no reason to get emotional, stopped the count to leave for a meeting over the lunch hour, and declined to leave when initially asked until law enforcement arrived and he left willingly.
Gina Messamer, representing Norris, highlighted the numerous committees Norris had served on and stated he was invited in 2023 to serve on the post election audit committee, making sure everything was done by the vote, and was then invited in 2024 to serve on the absentee ballot committee by Ozuna.
“One caveat he had is he had a work commitment over the lunch hour. So he said, I’d love to do this, but I have this commitment. The auditor said, no problem. The auditor emailed the whole group and said, Joey has this commitment over the lunch hour. That’d be a good time to take our lunch break and then we can reconvene and the board can finish their work after lunch,” commented Messamer.
Messamer advised the jury Joey didn’t receive any training from the auditor. All the auditor did was email them a copy of a guidebook that’s put together by the Secretary of State’s office to all different election officials, and that Norris printed that guidebook out, read it carefully in advance of the day, and highlighted important sections, as well as bringing it the day of the count. He then asked for a change in the way the ballots were opened, which was accepted, questioned the procedure for accepting a ballot with an X vote, and expressed concerns rejected ballots wouldn’t be counted, as there is an 8 p.m. deadline to come and fix the vote to be counted. Norris was told that the voters were contacted after all votes had been counted. Norris suggested they be contacted earlier, then suggested that if there was no time for that, the names be given to the observers, Jan Norris and Dan Bullington, to contact them. Norris was later removed from the board, and left without incident after a Montgomery County Deputy was called.
Duden first called Ozuna to the stand. Ozuna reiterated the role of the absentee ballot committee, and that the members swore an oath. Ozuna said there was to be no interaction between the board and the poll watchers. The 10 p.m. deadline to complete ballots was not flexible. Ozuna howver stated that Norris communicated with his mother, Jan Norris, on more than one occasion, and he was advised not to. Ozuna couldn’t say whether he didn’t understand or didn’t care about the rule. She also advised that when Norris suggested the ballot without the oval be filled in, she refused.
“It’s the optical scanner’s job to count the votes, not mine, not the board’s. It goes against Iowa Code, Chapter 52. We just don’t do that, but we’ve had to argue about that a lot. I called the former auditor for Black Hawk County, to confirm my understanding that one wasn’t supposed to look at the ballot. The absentee book on that vote section does say that the auditor may instruct. However, that instruct is designated specifically for an instance where the optical scanner is not going to read the ballot or in the process of, say, a power outage and the scanners can’t work, then you’re going to mark a ballot. There’s specific ways of how you have to even do that. Joey wanted us to mark in those ballots, and he even made the reference that it wasn’t even for someone he would vote for. It’s a violation of that secrecy of that person who just did that vote,” Stated Ozuna.
Due to the interruptions, Ozuna said one batch of ballots with two rejected was accidentally accepted, resulting in all the ballots up to that point needing to be recounted. Ozuna felt Norris was to blame.
“I think because it was so much arguing, so much interruption. It was hard to focus when there’s a lot of behavior going on by Mr. Norris. He kept referring to the handbook that says the auditor may instruct the absentee board to mark the ballot. But it certainly didn’t require me to do it. The Secretary of State affirmed that as well,” Ozuna said.
Ozuna also testified she was surprised to find the door to the absentee counting room locked at noon, and felt there was no reason the process should have been stopped unless everyone wanted to go to lunch, as well as believing it affected the board’s ability to complete its counting responsibility on time. Ozuna stated she told Norris he was impeding the process and warned him twice on his conduct. Around 3:15, Norris was asked to leave, and contacted her peers to make sure her actions were validated.
“It was a very tense environment. He argued and refused to leave. He said I didn’t have the authority to make him leave. He said that I would have to call Jon Spunaugle, the sheriff. I did call law enforcement, and when they arrived, he sat back in his chair and said, ‘I think the board should have to take a vote.’ I told them that’s not their job. I appointed him, and I unappointed him, and he was out,” said Ozuna.
Ozuna testified that after Norris was removed from the board, the process went smoothly, and of the 10 voters with rejected ballots, eight were contacted and were able to correct their ballots in time.
Under cross-examination, Messamer highlighted an email sent on Oct. 31, where she advised the full absentee team about Norris’ noon conflict on election day. It advised that Joey had a Zoom meeting at noon and that may be a good time to convene for lunch, but said it was only a suggestion and only if they all chose to go to lunch. Messamer countered that wasn’t written in Ozuna’s email, though Ozuna reiterated she said may be a good time for lunch. At 9 a.m., the board was not instructed when to take lunch.
When prompted about Norris being the only member of the absentee ballot committee to bring his rulebook, Ozuna initially thanked him and she felt it showed that he read it and cared about the procedures. She also confirmed that Norris’ suggestion to change the procedure for opening the ballots, having the affidavit placed face down so it couldn’t be read, per the guidebook. There was comment that they never really looked at the affidavit, but there was no objection to changing the procedure.
When it came to filling the ballot oval, Ozuna confirmed Norris was referring to code in the guidebook. As for the code referenced, it was not information provided in the absentee rulebook and would have had to been researched separately by Norris.
“It states the auditor may instruct the board to mark over the unreadable mark with a pen or pencil that can be read by the voting machine. I spoke to my colleague in Black Hawk County, He was our Iowa Code grandfather of auditors, highly respected, highly known for being very well-versed in Iowa Code. I read the full code section after lunch, and the ballot was run through the scanner. Joey never tried to mark the ballot himself, he wanted me to instruct the board to mark the ballot,” said Ozuna.
Absentee ballot workers are unable to speak with poll watchers. Observers cannot interfere with duties of the absentee board. Interference includes, but is not limited to, handling ballots and communicating or attempting to communicate information regarding the progress of the count while the board is counting ballots. Observers are allowed to get the names of people whose ballots are rejected. Under the testimony, Ozuna confirmed that Norris did not inform Jan Norris about the progress of the count, and asked to share the names of those with rejected ballots to the observers, both of which are specifically allowed by the rules.
At no point, Ozuna testified, did Norris get loud, or physical, curse Ozuna, call her names, or do anything violent. All of his interactions were verbal. After the incident, she contacted the county attorney, who said he was given a directive by the attorney general to refer incidents. She received witness statement forms from Montgomery County Deputy Drew Askey. Forms were given to everyone in the room at the time of the incident except for Joey and Jan Norris. Upon the statements being returned, they were turned over to Askey.
Among the other witnesses called to the stand were absentee ballot workers that were in the room, Julie Rubey, Clint Rubey, Jeanice Lester, and Will Lester. The issue over when the lunch break was taken was repeatedly referenced. Julie Rubey, testifying for the prosecution, recalled Norris saying that they all had to leave while he was away at his noon meeting. Angela Brown, testifying for the defense, said that Norris didn’t order her to leave, she had planned on leaving anyway, and that Norris had said the room needed to be locked and protected in everyone’s absence.
Both the Rubeys and the Lesters testified they felt Joey impeded the process in various ways, while Will Lester testified that Norris’ presence was “chaotic and disruptive.” Brown recalled in her testimony that Norris was “strong-willed” but “calm” and kept referencing the guide book. All of the workers testified that there were concerns of not making the absentee ballot counting deadline of 10 p.m., and that after Norris left, the deadline was reached.
As to the scanner issue with the ballots being incorrectly accepted, Julie Rubey, in her testimony, said they had challenges with the scanner all the time and it was not unusual to have to run ballots through several times, even going so far as to call the machine “fussy.” All testified that Norris initially refused to leave the room where ballots were counted, but that when law enforcement was called, he left without incident.
Under testimony from Jan Norris one of the two observers, she recalled that Joey Norris’ request to modify the way the ballots were handled was initially met with pushback by the board, before later being adopted as proper procedure. She also testified that the atmosphere was affable in the morning, but became less so as the day progressed. She testified that Joey Norris didn’t order anyone to leave the room for the lunch hour and that in her observation, everyone left willingly.
All the members who testified said that Norris never shouted, raised his voice, made threatening moves or gestures, nor called anyone names. When the situation was investigated, it was confirmed that everyone but Joey and Jan Norris were given witness statements and that no one was contacted by law enforcement, though both Jan and Joey Norris said they’d have been happy to speak to them.
Joey Norris also went to the witness stand and testified in his own defense, reiterating that when he was asked to serve on the board, he advised about the lunch hour conflict and was told it should be no issue. Based on the email, it was his understanding that everyone would break for lunch when he left. When asked about training, he said received no specific training, but that on the Thursday or Friday before the election, received an email with the guidebook for absentee ballot counters, the poll watchers poster and guidebook, and one other document he couldn’t recall.
Portions of Norris’ guidebook were entered into evidence. Norris admitted that he has no knowledge of what the Iowa Codebook said in regards to elections. Norris referenced the ballot with the “x” instead of a filled out circle, and recalled asking Ozuna what to do with it. Norris referenced the guidebook, which stated the auditor may instruct the board to mark over the unreadable marks with pen or pencil to be read by the voting machine. Norris testified Ozuna left the room and returned with law that said it couldn’t be filled in unless it was rejected by the machine. When it was run, the ballot was counted, and Norris said that was the end of the conversation.
During the lunch hour, Norris testified that he told the board he needed to leave, and asked one of the members representing the majority party to leave with him so there was no imbalance. Norris referenced the guidebook which stated the board could not be out of balance by more than one. Norris said he stood by the door, and someone, not him, suggested they all leave at one time.
Referencing the rejected ballots, Norris testified there was no training, and the rejected ballots went into a sealed envelope and the affected voters would be contacted. Norrs said he did not personally ask to contact the people, and suggested giving the names to the poll watchers, as in the poll watcher’s guide, it said they could know the names. Norris testified he was not allowed to do so.
When he was asked to leave, Norris said he was shocked, as up to then he felt he had been a valuable member of the board, and felt upset.
“I’m an Eagle Scout. I take something I swore an oath to do seriously. The thought of being removed was a failure of my duties,” Norris said.
Under cross-examination, Duden confirmed that Norris had interacted with his mother Jan, and asked for details about the issue of the rejected ballots. Norris didn’t recall talking specifically about them.
“She raised the issue of the rejected ballots, and I told her that she could come and look at them,” Norris said.
Duden said that the count was still in progress at that point, and felt that could include names or numbers on rejected ballots, though Norris didn’t believe so, and cited his own information that any observer could have the names of the people in the rejected ballot box. Duden reiterated that the guidebook didn’t say Norris could communicate with his mother, and that Ozuna said there was to be no communication between the absentee board and observers. He also reiterated the slow progress made before Norris left versus afterwards.
When asked if he recalled telling Ozuna not to become emotional, Norris testified that he remembered saying he thought they were getting emotional. As for his refusal to initially leave, it was because he felt the board was an independent entity of the auditor and that she didn’t have the authority to remove him, though he could not cite a specific reference in the guidebook, but was happy to review. Duden referenced the fact that the count proceeded more smoothly after Norris left, though Norris testified he had no concerns they would meet the deadline, and cited the slowness of the morning due to waiting for the machine to be activated and ballots to arrive.
Under closing arguments, Duden stated that when Norris was present, the count was slowed, impeded, or hindered.
“Audtitor Ozuna testified that Norris’ actions and his conduct during the day when he was in the room slowed the board’s work for hours. Julie Rubey, Clint Rubey, Jeanice Lester, and Will Lester all explained it as Mr. Norris’ actions impeded the progress, it made it difficult to focus and slowed things down, The delays were attributed to one person, the defendant,” Duden said.
Duden said the state proved that Norris was an election official, that he willfully performed his duties as an election official and did so in such a way as to hinder or disregard the object of the law, that stopping to deal with the rejected ballots instead of processing those filled out correctly hindered the process, and reiterated that the count was done at 9:35 p.m., with only 25 minutes to spare before missing the deadline.
Messamer disagreed in her closing arguments, referencing the lack of training given, and reiterating that Norris was the only one who brought his guidebook with him. She questioned whether the issues arose from the new board member questioning the procedures of the people who had done it on a long-term basis, and that Norris was focused on the task at hand.
“Joey brings up that he notices a ballot not filled out correctly, so his intent is to have the ballot counted. What a terrible thing for him to want to do. Everyone is offended he would bring this up and point out there was a procedure to make sure the ballot would be run through correctly. He did nothing inappropriate with the ballot himself,” stated Messamer. “He didn’t go ahead and mark it, he just brought up the process to make sure the vote counts, consistent with his responsibilities in trying to fulfill the object of this voting law.”
Messamer added that the state hadn’t proved that Norris had willingly hindered or disregarded the object of the law.
“He volunteers for everything. He’s never had a problem like this, if he did, he wouldn’t be invited to other boards to participate. He’s not a person who comes in to be a squeaky wheel and cause drama, he volunteered. He read the rules, even corrected a procedure, spoke respectfully and abided by the rules and the auditor’s guidance. At the end of the day, he helped by trying to make sure every vote counted, and that Joey did not act without approval,” stated Messamer.
The jury began deliberations at around 5 p.m. on Oct. 8, and returned with a unanimous not guilty verdict at around 8:45 p.m. that same evening
