Miner Queries: Nuclear negotiations: is war the only answer?
On the Monday after Easter as I was scanning the morning headlines, I came across this on AlterNet: “The Same Right-Wing Bozos Who Lied the U.S. into Iraq Are Peddling Nonsense About Obama’s Iran Deal.”
The article by Steve Rosenfeld highlighted a new short video by Brave New Films that pairs footage from the run-up to Iraq with clips from current discussions of the Iran nuclear negotiations. Many of the same characters (Benjamin Netanyahu, Lindsey Graham and John Bolton) are saying virtually the same thing 14 years later.
What did that warmongering get us?
As Rosenfeld notes, America spent $4 trillion on the Iraq War, losing more than 6,800 soldiers, wounding more than 52,000 and leaving even more with post-traumatic stress injuries. Additionally, more than 154,000 Iraqi civilians were killed. And if that isn’t enough, our continuing military actions feed the hate that fuels terrorism.
Then, on Wednesday morning as I continued to follow developments with the historic agreement brokered by America and its allies, Greg Sargent’s Washington Post Plum Line blog led with this headline: “When it comes to war, Congress has a double standard.”
In covering Congress’ concerns about the Iran deal and how to curb executive power over negotiations, Sargent noted legislators seemed to have lost sight of executive authority on war powers. He also credited Sen. Chris Murphy with pointing out the double standard: “I’m first in line to reassert the power of Congress to stand next to the executive on foreign policy,” Murphy continues. “We have a Constitutional obligation to approve or disapprove of the war against ISIS. We do not have a Constitutional obligation to approve or disapprove an executive agreement with Iran.”
Consequently, Murphy has been one voice cautioning his congressional colleagues on legislation that might scuttle negotiations toward a peaceful settlement with Iran over their nuclear capabilities.
As Navy veteran and securities studies instructor Shaun VanDiver wrote on TalkingPoints Memo about the agreement: “Under the framework released, Iran’s pathways to a nuclear weapon are cut off. Enrichment of uranium is severely limited, the heavy water reactor at Arak will not reprocess plutonium, and Iran will be the toughest inspections and transparency regime for any nuclear program in history. Facilities and stockpiles once very worrying to the world will be modified, closed or shipped abroad.”
VanDiver adds the details of the final agreement will be important. But he and many other veterans of our latest Middle East adventures are glad to see a possible diplomatic solution forming. They are not anxious for another fight.
Nor am I. I vividly remember the diligent work of the International Atomic Energy Agency’s inspectors on the ground in Iraq searching for weapons of mass destruction in 2002-03. But before they could complete their work, they were pulled out of the country so we could begin our invasion. No WMDs have ever been found in Iraq.
Yet as Van Diver notes, the Iran agreement includes the toughest inspections and transparency regime in history. Do we want a nuclear-free Iran, or do we want perpetual war?
I don’t think citizens asked enough questions about the push for war last time; Congress certainly didn’t. I don’t want to make the same mistake again.
If you prefer negotiations to more war, let Senators Grassley and Ernst and Representative Young know now.
Cherie Miner is a local parent, community volunteer, freelance writer and artist. In a former life, she was a corporate writer and public relations professional. Contact her at news@redoakexpress.com or on Facebook.
