Mandatory trash a good idea
When I first moved to Red Oak a little more than a year ago, a few things struck me as odd about this community and state.
Fireworks are illegal because they are too dangerous, but riding a motorcycle without a helmet isn’t.
There is no property tax on my car or boat.
There are black squirrels.
And the trash service isn’t a monopoly chosen for you. There are multiple providers in town, and none of them are mandatory.
At least, not right now.
The Red Oak City Council may soon be changing that as they will be discussing the idea of mandatory trash pick-up at its July 19 meeting.
Partially spawned from the problem of people dumping trash at the city brush pile, the Council views this as a potential solution.
However, I wonder how it will be implemented. In previous communities where I’ve lived and trash service was required, the fee was simply tacked on to the water bill.
Everyone with a water bill was charged X number of dollars for trash as well. The money the city collected for trash was then transferred to the provider, who secured the contract through a bid process.
That bid process has some advantages. When a provider can secure an entire town, the volume goes up dramatically, driving down costs for the individual consumer.
In fact, the last town I lived in just re-bid their services which resulted in the first price increase in more than 10 years. In addition to regular weekly trash pickup, residents receive a free 40-gallon can to store their trash, there is a yearly bulk trash pickup, curbside recycling, brush pickup, and one large item per week can be disposed of free of charge.
All of this costs the residents about $6 a month less than what I’m currently paying in Red Oak.
That’s a lot of extra services for more than $70 less a year. Quite a deal.
But there is a downside. Like I said, everyone with a water hookup gets a trash charge as well, including those who live in apartments and may have a dumpster outside at their disposal.
Too bad for you is the City’s mindset.
And naturally, the other downside is your options are eliminated. You can’t switch trash providers just because you want to.
(One other thing I’ll mention about this proposal. It increases the size of government, while eliminating personal choice and freedom, a very anti-Republican approach to a problem. I just wanted to mention that irony as I doubt anyone will oppose this based on that reason.)
I’m not saying this will be, or should be, Red Oak’s approach. But the bottom line is there can be more than one benefit to mandatory trash pick up. Just be prepared for the negative consequences that go with it.
Gregory Orear is the general manager/editor of the Red Oak Express. He can be emailed at publisher@redoakexpress.com.
