Magazine differences compared

I recently browsed through two magazines, the first of which was published in the spring of 1959. Intended for housewives, the content was mostly recipes, interior decorating, parenting, and clothing. The second magazine was the April 2010 issue, one of today’s most popular publications for women.

The magazine of fifty years ago contained 102 pages, the latter has 264. Both featured the latest in styles for spring and suggestions for summertime fun. The recipes are similar but different, as are clothing and furniture and hair styles. The most glaring difference in the magazines themselves, however, is the advertising.

Our fifty-year-old publication contained a few small, boxed-in ads plus a couple of pages of classifieds. The entire 102 pages included the equivalent of six pages of advertising, or slightly more than 5%. In the 2009 edition we find glitzy, full page ads galore. Of 264 cover to cover pages, 165 are entirely advertising. This does not count recipes which recommend, and therefore promote, certain brand name products, nor does it include feature article references to places or products followed by a note on where and how to purchase. Advertising in the latter publication is, in fact, so predominant yet so subtle it is difficult to distinguish between the impartial and the sales pitch. A couple of paragraphs and handful of pictures of a kitchen remodel are sandwiched between multiple pages of ads for faucets and flooring and appliances. The 2010 magazine also has an additional 39 pages of advertising inserts and several annoying post cards.

A reader perusing the entire 303 pages will view well over 200 pages of commercials. 5% advertising content 50 years ago has become nearly 70% today, and even more when the imbedded promotions are taken into account.

And it’s not just printed material. Google up an informational web site and be prepared for more ads than news, including floating pop-ups you have to chase to remove. Buying anything over the internet means giving up your email, which means whoever you bought from will stuff your in-box with unwanted information on their latest sale, and using the “opt-out” feature is taken as proof the ad has reached someone and your address may be sold to others. Telemarketers are as determined as ever and “Do-Not-Call” regulations so full of loopholes as to be all but useless. If you’ve ever contributed to a charity, used a credit card or purchased anything you’ve established a ‘business relationship’ and are fair game to be hounded by callers wanting to sell you more.

Without advertising the internet wouldn’t be free and the cost of magazine subscriptions much higher. But clearly the public is being fed more and more hype and less and less substance, and we wonder how far the trend will go.

Roy Marshall is a local historian. E-mail him at news@redoakexpress.com.

The Red Oak Express

222 E. Coolbaugh St.
P.O. Box 377
Red Oak, IA 51566
Phone: 712-623-2566 Fax: 712-623-2568

Comment Here