Letter to | the Editor

To the Editor:

Brad Hicks’ recent column in the Express caused me to think about Internet data collection.

Nearly 20 years ago, many people in the online community were concerned about hackers, both in and out of government, getting into their computers to steal data and/or sabotage their computers. Today many if not most people store their data – both personal and public – “in the cloud,” where anybody who wants it can get it, given sufficient motivation; and in the case of government snoops, without a search warrant because the courts have ruled that personal data held by third parties (i.e. ISPs, credit bureaus, “in the cloud,” banks, hospitals, etc.) is not protected by the Fourth Amendment.

Many years ago – long before the World Wide Web was invented – a fellow named Clifford Stoll wrote a book titled “The Cuckoo’s Egg,” which is about the search for and eventual capture of a hacker in eastern Europe who was stealing data from university and government computers. Mr. Stoll wrote two other books that weren’t nearly as good as his first, but his “Silicon Snake Oil” is a very good explanation of why computers should NOT be in the schools. I happen to agree with him; schools are supposed to be teaching students how to think, not how to run computers or surf the Internet.

Over the last decade or so there have been MANY articles written about various data breaches and thefts of data, and yet people continue to allow their data to be stored where it can be accessed by anybody on the Internet. I don’t, but personal data about me is stored on computers accessible from the Internet by various data collection companies. I’d like to see a massive class-action lawsuit against these data collectors when their databases are hacked or breached, a heavy hit to their bank accounts should get that data off of machines that are accessed from the Internet. In my opinion, the fact that the data is accessible is ipso facto proof of negligence.

I know about firewalls and other security measures, and I simply note that anything one human mind can devise another human mind can devise a way around. I also know that Microsoft’s operating systems and applications, from MS-DOS to the current version of Windows, have been notorious for their poor design and lack of security for over 30 years. My philosophy is “they can’t get in through a connection that doesn’t exist,” and I disconnected my computers from the Internet in 2005. If I absolutely MUST use the Internet, I use the public machines available at most local libraries, and I take a thumb drive with me to save any data I may wish to keep.

All of that having been said, I find the news that various Internet companies and “smart phones” are literally spying on people to be troubling. That’s why I don’t – and won’t – have a smart phone and minimize the time I spend on the Internet.

I’m also troubled by the practice of “law enforcement” that gets its pet judges to sign search warrants that basically say “any kind of electronic equipment” and then grab everything in sight that has a plug or a keypad on it, even if the alleged crime is jaywalking. And I note that if “law enforcement” can’t find anything on that equipment there’s nothing stopping them from planting evidence on it and claiming it was always there. If “law enforcement” deigns to return any of the confiscated equipment to its owner, it will probably be damaged beyond hope of repair; the owner, of course, has no recourse.

The Fourth Amendment to the Constitution requires that a search warrant specifically describe what is being searched for, and “any kind of electronic equipment” isn’t specific, nor does it say what evidence is being searched for; “any evidence of a crime” isn’t specific, either; the Fifth Amendment to the constitution says that a person cannot be forced to testify – provide evidence – against himself. Recently, “law enforcement” has tried to have its Constitutionally-challenged pet judges force citizens to provide the keys to unlock or decrypt data on their computers and “smart phones” – thus possibly providing evidence that can be used against them; it seems to me that violates the Fifth Amendment, not that “law enforcement” cares about that sort of thing. Some months back Apple got a lot of bad press from our Constitutionally-illiterate media for refusing to assist “law enforcement” in breaking into someone’s iPhone. I think Apple was correct.

Apple also got some bad press for updating its operating system to close a security loophole that “law enforcement” has been exploiting; the July 11 edition of USA Today has an article about that in its Money section.

About 25 years ago, a fellow named Philip Zimmerman came up with a software package he called “Pretty Good Privacy” (PGP) and released it to the public – for free. The government wanted to throw him in jail forever because spooks couldn’t break his encryption system. It took years, but the government finally took PGP away from Zimmerman and gave it to a company (RSA Associates) run by its stooges; versions of PGP sold by RSA Associates (version numbers higher than 3.0) undoubtedly have “back doors” in them that allow government spooks and “law enforcement” to decrypt files encrypted with them. Citizens of this country are not allowed to have encryption programs that the government cannot break.

Robert L. Ackley

Emerson

The Red Oak Express

222 E. Coolbaugh St.
P.O. Box 377
Red Oak, IA 51566
Phone: 712-623-2566 Fax: 712-623-2568

Comment Here