HOW DID THIS HAPPEN?

RED OAK — It was about 6:50 a.m. on a clear Sunday morning when a 130-car, 18,000-ton Burlington Northern Santa Fe coal train passed a wayside signal, warning the trains’ crew of an approaching train.

And while a stationary 21-car train hauling maintenance equipment was visible from more than a quarter-mile away, the coal train’s speed increased and the emergency brakes were not applied before a violent collision killed two people.

Federal investigators are still trying to figure out why.

The National Transportation and Safety Board released its preliminary report last week into the April 17 train accident west of Red Oak that claimed the lives of BNSF Conductor Patricia Hyatt and Engineer Tom Anderson, both 48, and both of Creston.

After the trains collided flames engulfed the coal train’s lead locomotive, while derailing the second and two cars. Seven additional fully-loaded coal cars were also damaged.

The standing maintenance equipment train, which consisted of 21 loaded and 13 empty cars, had nine cars derailed, but the engineer and conductor were uninjured.

NTSB investigators will now review personnel, maintenance and other various records, including cell phone records, which have been subpoenaed.

According to the preliminary report, trains in the area operate on wayside signal indications visible to the crew. Signal system data indicate the last signal encountered by the coal train was set at “restricting,” requiring the train to be prepared to stop short of another train.

Information obtained from the event recorder indicated just before the collision, the coal train’s speed increased and the throttle was decreased as the train reached the top of a hill west of the accident site. After speeding up just before impact, the train had reached a speed of 23 miles per hour.

The crew of the maintenance train, which included an engineer and a conductor, said visibility at the time of the collision was good. Investigators conducted sight distance observations under similar daylight and weather conditions. Observers were able to identify the standing train about 1,376 feet from the point of collision.

NTSB spokesperson Keith Holloway said investigators are determining if that was adequate distance to stop a train of that size at that speed, if the brakes had been applied.

“That is going to require more analysis of the event recorder,” Holloway said. “To go into hypotheticals such as that, we can’t elaborate on specifics until we are farther into the investigation.”

Holloway said the event recorder has been sent to Washington D.C. for further analysis of preliminary information regarding the train’s speed, brakes, and throttle.

A video camera on the coal train’s lead locomotive was destroyed in the fire.
 

The Red Oak Express

222 E. Coolbaugh St.
P.O. Box 377
Red Oak, IA 51566
Phone: 712-623-2566 Fax: 712-623-2568

Comment Here