Hedge apples drive away spiders

Do hedge apples really drive spiders out of basements? Lots of people, mostly in the Midwest, swear they do. The experts at Iowa State University, however, have a contrary opinion.

Hedge apples, which are produced by female Osage orange trees, are also called horse apples, hedge balls, monkey balls, Missouri grapefruit, and mock oranges. The trees, which can be thorny nuisances, have numerous qualities. Commonly planted in our county in the mid to late 1800s as living fences, they reportedly worked quite well. The wood is rot-resistant. Fence posts made of hedge, old-timers say, will endure for at least a century. After fifty years of wind and rain and hail the exposed part of the post shows some wear, at which time the post can be dug up, turned over, and will serve for another fifty years.

Many who craft wooden bows claim hedge makes a stronger bow than any other wood, even yew. Dry hedge wood will burn hotter than some grades of coal. Furniture made of hedge has a yellow-orange color comparable to nothing else, with intriguing grain and growth patterns. A number of noted makers of musical instruments use it because they believe hedge, under duress, is the most dimensionally stable of all wood.

But does the fruit repel spiders or other insects? Each summer our basement plays host to an annoying gathering of wispy little spiders. Each autumn I put down a few hedge apples. Within days the spiders are gone. This is true, and has taken place year after year. Countless other people attest to similar experiences, but might this be a coincidence? Might the insect exit be a part of some natural cycle; something that has nothing to do with the hedge apples?

A 1997 report published by the horticulture department of Iowa State University states, in part,the following:

“The use of hedge apples as a pest solution is communicated as a folk tale complete with testimonials about apparent success. However, there is an absence of scientific research and therefore no valid evidence to support the claims of effectiveness. Although insect deterrent compounds have beenextracted from hedge apples in laboratory studies, these do not provide a logical explanation as to why hedge apples would work as claimed. At this time, there is nothing to recommend the use of hedge apples for pest control.”

Yes, read that again. Read particularly the sentence that tells us the proven presence of insect deterring compounds in hedge apples does not provide a logical explanation as to why the apples might deter insects.

Whether the I.S.U. report makes sense or not, a lot of old wives and I will continue to use hedge apples as long as they work. And who knows? Someday some scholarly study might confirm that the hedge apple’s insect deterring compounds actually deter insects.

Roy Marshall is a local historian. E-mail him at news@redoakexpress.com.

The Red Oak Express

222 E. Coolbaugh St.
P.O. Box 377
Red Oak, IA 51566
Phone: 712-623-2566 Fax: 712-623-2568

Comment Here