Guest Editorial | Zach Kinser
School consolidation is always a complicated issue, especially in rural communities where a school is often the central component to a particular community’s identity. The communities located here in southwest Iowa are good examples of this phenomenon, but is it always good for a school to be the foundation of a town’s identity?
The recent discussions between Villisca and Stanton about possible whole-grade sharing (i.e. consolidation) prove that communities are often unwilling to let go of a perceived identity even if the future of the community is at stake.
Make no mistake, both the future of Villisca and Stanton are dependent on having a school. Neither community would exist (at least in its current form, but most likely at all) for long if their school closed. For both communities to not only survive but to grow, improve, and flourish they will need to creatively solve some important problems. A collective open-mind is essential to successfully bridging the gap between now and the future.
What some people have been overlooking is the fact that Villisca and Stanton are much more alike than different. Both communities are proud and have continually shown the solidarity that makes small, rural towns and their residents so unique. Each community has come together in order to help individuals and families through difficult times, so why can’t these communities come together to do what is best for both Villisca and Stanton?
If the schools decided to consolidate, I imagine both communities would prefer to have the high school in their town. This is a tough problem to overcome but an unwillingness to objectively research and do what is best for the students is unacceptable. Eliminating options without a tangible, rational reason and taking things off the metaphorical negotiating table is short-sighted. Each school has its limitations and problems. Negotiations should spotlight these shortcomings in order to address the issue and look for a solution. Instead, these limitations and problems are being used as ammunition against one another. As a result, Villisca and Stanton community members are becoming more divided while community stereotypes are being reinforced. Everyone is losing.
I grew up in Stanton, went to school in Stanton, and graduated from Stanton. I am proud of my community, but I am unwilling to accept stubbornness, short-sightedness, and pride as the reason why Stanton and its school does not survive into the future. The meetings between Villisca and Stanton should have been a way to highlight the good facets of our (Stanton’s) community and school while providing an opportunity for us to address our school’s limitations. However, the only palpable results, thus far, has been the alienation of Villisca and its community members.
I have heard different reasons and justifications for why the negotiations have gone this way, some more defensible than others. But regardless of your rationale, attacking and alienating the Villisca community and school is unjustified and ultimately detrimental to Stanton’s future. For example, if Villisca consolidates with Corning there would be some families that decided to open-enroll their children to Stanton, but these negotiations have undoubtedly left a bitter taste in the mouths of some of those families. The Stanton community and school need to recognize the mistakes that have been made and own up to those mistakes. Otherwise, Stanton is risking further damage to its own future by the continued alienation of the Villisca community and school.
Stanton’s community identity is so intertwined with the school that the two are indistinguishable from one another (as I am sure is the case in Villisca also).
Admitting that the school may fail is the same as admitting the community will fail too, a tough pill to swallow for proud community members.
However, if the collective mind of Stanton cannot admit the limitations the future (including: educational funding, an aging community, etc.) will inherently place on our community and school is reckless.
Denial is counter-productive to the long-term goal of sustaining the community.
I know school consolidation is a complex and sensitive subject and that the merging of Villisca and Stanton’s school (in whatever fashion) is the same as consolidating the community identities of the two communities.
But why would this would be a bad thing? What if the two communities could bring out the best in each other?
What if?
Zack Kinser is a 2007 Stanton High School graduate, and a 2011 graduate of the University of Iowa. He can be contacted at zkinser15@gmail.com.
