Guest Editorial: This will last longer than four hours

 No need to worry, Hobby Lobby is still providing it’s employees with Viagra as part of their company-wide health care plan.

Ladies and gentleman needn’t be concerned. That, ahem, reproductive health care issue is covered.

That must come as a tremendous relief to Hobby Lobby’s thousands of female employees.

Last month, the Supreme Court ruled 5-4 in favor of a large group of corporate plaintiffs led by Hobby Lobby that would exempt companies with religious objections to providing certain birth control devices for its employees. The craft store chain, which is predominantly owned by the Green family, was ruled a “tightly held” company and therefore, they will not have to provide those birth control options it deems objectionable; namely, the Plan B pill, the Ella “morning after” pill and two types of intrauterine device (IUD). Hobby Lobby has, and does supply access to a dozen other forms of birth control to employees as part of it’s health care but there’s no telling how this Supreme Court decision might embolden further “objections” down the road. 

That’s enough to make the hair stand up on the back of my neck.

I can’t be the only person in the world that finds this trending opposition to providing women’s reproductive health care on “religious grounds” ridiculously hypocritical and bigoted.

According to the Guttmacher Institute, a sexual and reproductive health policy group, 99 percent of women aged 15–44 who have had sexual intercourse have used at lease one contraceptive method at some point in their life. Liberal women and conservative women, Christian women and atheist women fall into that 99 percent, obviously. More than 60 percent of all women of reproductive age are using a form of birth control right now.

But let’s set the record straight, Hobby Lobby isn’t declining to provide all reproductive health care and along with that, they are also not refusing to cover contraception. It’s a popular misconception but Hobby Lobby simply isn’t capable of doing this – they are legally required to provide contraception as part of a comprehensive health care plan. The issue then revolves around which contraception, as part of the Affordable Care Act’s reproductive health care portion, Hobby Lobby is “comfortable” providing their employees.

The Green family, which owns the arts-and-crafts chain, stated its position in regard to the Supreme Court case on the Hobby Lobby website.

“The Greens and their family businesses respect the individual liberties of all their employees,” a statement read. “The Greens and their family businesses have no objection to the other 16 FDA-approved contraceptives required by the law that do not interfere with the implantation of a fertilized egg. They provide coverage for such contraceptives under their health care plan. Additionally, the four objectionable drugs and devices are widely available and affordable, and employees are free to obtain them.”

That’s well stated and more than a bit disingenuous. How readily are you to essentially allow your employer to choose your birth control for you? 

The whole idea is unseemly and smacks of a conservative Christian agenda power grab.

Along the logic set forth in the Hobby Lobby decision, it’s really not such a leap to imagine a company refusing any medical coverage according to their closely held religious beliefs. 

You don’t need a psychiatrist. Prayer will cure your bi-polar. No more chiropractic care, they might say, because God gave you a sore back for a reason. Need some orthodontia? Sorry. You were born with those crooked teeth.

Defenders of the decision all say the same thing: if you want it, pay for it yourself. Well, I don’t know how health insurance works at Hobby  Lobby but if it’s anything like my plan, then they are paying for their health care. Shouldn’t that entitle one to choose their own reproductive health care?

And just so we’re clear, an IUD – which is the fifth most popular form of birth control in the U.S. and, contrary to the Green’s opinion, is not an abortifacient – is morally objectionable but a vasectomy for a man, that’s just fine? It’s this kind of cherry picking on a baseless moral high ground that makes me question if the real motivation is Christian values or sexual subjugation.

Reproductive decisions should be made by just two people: those using the contraception and the doctors prescribing it. Not Susie’s boss in the floral department or a C.F.O. with a chip on his shoulder for loose women. And that’s not even the worst part. What’s really scary is 50 other companies apparently feel the same way.

The Red Oak Express

222 E. Coolbaugh St.
P.O. Box 377
Red Oak, IA 51566
Phone: 712-623-2566 Fax: 712-623-2568

Comment Here