Gov. Branstad denies Dyess’ commutation appeal
GRISWOLD — A Griswold woman will remain in prison for killing two children in a 2005-house fire she set after Iowa Gov. Terry Branstad denied her appeal for clemency Friday.
Tracey Dyess, 25, is serving a 45-year sentence after her 2006 conviction of manslaughter stemming from the deaths of her 13-year-old sister and 6-year-old nephew.
The children were killed in a fire Dyess admitted to setting in March 2005 at her Griswold home. She later told investigators she was trying to kill her stepfather, Brian Street, who had been sexually molesting her. Street was later convicted of sexual molestation and sentenced to 30 years in prison.
Street and Dyess’ mother, Debbie, escaped alive.
Dyess was denied parole in July, and the parole board sent their recommendation to Branstad, who ultimately agreed Dyess should remain in prison.
“No one disputes that Ms. Dyess had a traumatic and abusive childhood. However, two innocent children died because of her actions and one crime does not justify another one,” Branstad wrote in a letter to the parole board denying Dyess’ application.
Dyess pleaded guilty to two counts of voluntary manslaughter, two counts of attempted murder and arson. She is currently serving her sentence in the state women’s prison in Mitchellville and her mandatory minimum sentence expires in 2022.
Branstad contended in his letter that prison has benefited Dyess.
“Ms. Dyess has made progress since she began serving her sentence and I believe more progress can be made. Accordingly, I am denying Tracey Ann Dyess’ application for commutation.”
Rev. John Zimmerman, who has advocated for Dyess’ release since she was sent to a Mt. Pleasant prison a mile from his home in 2006, maintains she has never received fair treatment from the justice system from the start.
“I think she should never have been charged with anything. She was raped daily by her stepfather.” Zimmerman said. “It seems to me if a rapist breaks into your house and tries to rape you and you try to kill them, it’s self defense. In this case, the rapist lived in her house and controlled her environment, so her attempt to end it went horribly bad in every way. But that’s not how she wanted it to happen.”
Zimmerman said when he visits Dyess, she always mentions the children killed in the fire, and he doesn’t believe she intended them any harm.
“She was a 17-year-old who was raped regularly and who had become aware her little sister was raped regularly. She was distraught and overwhelmed,” Zimmerman said. “If she had been thinking clearly, she’d at least have succeeded in killing Brian Street. I don’t have any doubt she didn’t have any intent to have them die.”
Zimmerman said had Dyess received clemency, his family was one that had been approved for her to live with.
“For her to be in prison as if she was a dangerous person … it is just not connected to the situation,” he said. “Tracey is such a sweet person. I’ve got to know her through letters and visits 5 years ago. She is a kind person, an intelligent person.”
Zimmerman also believes the person who is truly responsible for the death of the two children is already in jail.
“Brian Street is the reason those children are dead, not Tracey Dyess,” he said.
After visiting with Dyess just last week, Zimmerman said she is resigned to staying in prison until at least 2022, when she is eligible for early release.
“She has accepted the fact she will be in prison until she is in her mid-30s,” he said. “It took five years to get a ruling on this clemency appeal, so its pretty slow going. But the facts are out there, and either this governor or a future one can grant clemency at any time, so we will just have to see what happens.”
