Fabulous mustard, and Mother Podolak’s chili
Do you enjoy a dab of mustard on your hot dog, bratwurst, or breakfast cereal, but find the yellow tubs less than aesthetically pleasing?
Did you ever invert a squeeze bottle and douse your food with runny yellow water? Are you tired of plain old mustard? Would you like to try a genuine, old-fashioned Germ-an variety you make yourself, won’t separate, and tastes better than any you can buy?
If you answered yes to any of these questions Ida Schmitt McGaffin has good news.
Ida, the daughter of German immigrants, was born in Illinois in 1883. She married Alex McGaffin and moved to southwest Iowa to farm, raise three daughters, and do a lot of cooking.
Thresh-ers and hay-hands spread the word.
During the 1930s Ida was cooking for construction crews. Fifty road-builders took their dinner at Ida’s table, eating by rotation, dining there every workday all summer long.
Every meal had salads, meat, potatoes, vegetables hot and cold and pie or cake or whatever.
Always the mustard jar was passed. She made it by the quart, using a family recipe she refined. People wanted her German recipes, especially her mustard.
Her daughter has now revealed how Ida made it, and my wife and I agree there’s none to compare.
The recipe, and a plethora of others, can be found in “Southwest Iowa’s Greatest Recipes,” a fund-raising cookbook published in October.
The book also contains three chili recipes, one of them Mother Podolak’s.
We’ve gotten two columns out of Mother, and enough is enough, but an acquaintance called the other day with a story too good not to pass along.
Her chili, as most of you recall, became popular, closely associated with Hawkeye football, and in 1989 Hy-Vee began selling it.
The gentleman who called had just read the book. He asked that I not use his name or that of his grandmother, as she is still young enough to be embarrassed.
We’ll therefore call her grandma.
She knew Dorothy Podolak. One day, shortly after Hy-Vee introduced Mother Podolak’s Chili, grandma went shopping. She saw dozens of containers, assumed there to be more in a freezer in the back of the store. She thought of other Hy-Vee stores, pictured their freezers packed with Mother Podolak’s.
She was troubled by this, and as days passed became more so. By the time she next saw her grandson she was more than chagrined. Dorothy Podolak, she said, was a woman who had toiled on the farm, raised three children, worked hard all her life. Dorothy, grandma estimated, must be 70 years old. A grandmother. It was unthinkable that Hy-Vee would ask a woman of her age to make all that chili, hundreds of gallons of it.
Grandson explained the store had probably obtained just the recipe and the name, but grandma was not easily convinced. Dorothy was not that sort. Chili with her name on it would not have been fixed by anyone else.
If grandma happens to read this she may be disappointed. Dorothy was that sort.
She sold out and was proud of it, using the money to buy curtains for her living room. Hy-Vee’s corporate office could not tell me who made the chili, but it wasn’t Mrs. Podolak.
Incidentally, the representative I talked to asked for the recipe. She’d heard about it, but told me that once Hy-Vee stopped marketing Mother Podolak’s they lost the instructions.
I had no sympathy. Hy-Vee didn’t give the chili away. I told her the book was $10 and she’d have to buy a copy.
Roy Marshall is a local historian and columnist for the Red Oak Express. He can be reached at news@redoakexpress.com.
