Eyesore or a landmark?
RED OAK — With a new $6 million law enforcement center scheduled to be completed next year, the Montgomery County Board of Supervisors is trying to decide what to do with the current jail.
Supervisors started their decision making process by hosting a public meeting last week, with comments seemingly split between preserving the 111-year-old building and demolishing it.
“I usually don’t come down here, because I think you are running [the county] well, but the question you are even thinking about saving the jail I think is nuts,” Grant resident Roy Taylor said. “You told me for 10 years it is junk. It is beyond repair, and it needs to be torn down.”
Daric O’Neal, an architect who has worked with the city on developing a master plan for redevelopment of the downtown, said he believes all old buildings are worth saving.
“In my experience with an architecture firm that specializes in preserving historic buildings and saving them, and getting them modern usage, I believe the jail certainly has that capacity and potential,” O’Neal said. “Obviously, it didn’t work as a jail, but there is enough significance there, along with other things that are happening with the downtown Red Oak improvement master plan.”
Jacky Adams, who has purchased numerous historic buildings over the years including the Murphy Calendar Company, the Depot, and the former Kolterman store, also spoke in favor of saving the jail.
“Buildings can not be saved as monuments. And I firmly and absolutely believe that,” Adams said. “They have to have a purpose, they have to have an occupant, and they have to contribute to the welfare of the community they are in. This building can do all that if it has the opportunity.”
Supervisor Donna Robinson chaired the committee that successfully lobbied voters to approve funding the project. She believes the committee’s intentions were clear.
“The majority of those people (jail committee), their intention was for that building to go away,” Robinson said. “The idea was we were pressing forward we were coming up with a bond issue to take to the people to build a new law enforcement center and the old jail would go. It would be demolished. It would be either green space, area for parking, whatever.
“But the intention was not to put up this ... $6 million building to have an eyesore sitting next to it.”
Ken Rech, who served on that committee, echoed Robinson’s sentiments.
“I’m for looking at this building that it basically is in the position to about implode itself,” he said. “It lived its life. Let’s put it to its grave. We have other buildings around town we can focus on.”
Local realtor Henry Elliott said the County should consider shuttering the building, considering how inexpensive it is to insure it.
“I think we need to sit on it. It has a lot of possibilities,” Elliott said. “I think if you kept it you probably could be very successful in getting donations from people to maintain it for a while.”
Rech disagreed with the concept of saving a building for an indefinite amount of time and no plan in hand.
“So now we are going to build this new center and hide it with a building with no concept of what’s going to happen? We are going to sit on it,” Rech said. “How long are we going to sit on it? We don’t know. And we haven’t seen a lot of developers come and do anything.”
Elliott pointed out redevelopment of dilapidated buildings by out-of-town developers isn’t unprecedented in Red Oak.
“It wasn’t very long ago we were going to lose Coolbaugh Street on the south side all the way up. It came close to happening if Jacky hadn’t stepped in and did what she did,” Elliott said. “We lucked out with a buyer from out of town who came and fell in love with our downtown and look at the change compared to what it could have been with a big hole down there. Once you tear them down, they are gone forever.”
Connie Mellott submitted a written statement, stating she’s in favor of demolishing the building unless there was a buyer with the financial wherewithal who could immediately restore it.
“We don’t need it sold and then continue to have it sit in bad condition,” Mellott wrote. “The corridor to downtown and hopefully the downtown itself is being improved and that corner is an interlay that needs to be inviting. I don’t want anymore of my tax dollars being spent on this building except to demolish it.”
Supervisor Randy Tye agreed.
“I think preservation is an option, but you need to come up with a cost and a plan to take care of that,” he said. “I don’t believe in spending taxpayers money to preserve it for 10 years for nothing to happen.”
Supervisor Bryant Amos said last week’s meeting was the first step in determining what to do with the jail.
“I appreciate everyone’s input. This is not a decision we take lightly or will make immediately. We do still have time,” Amos said. “We want the public’s input and it will weigh on the decision we make at some point.”
