Eight is Enough: City Council offer varying opinions

RED OAK — Eight City Council candidates offered varying views on the downtown revitalization plan, funding for the YMCA, and trails project during last week’s candidate’s forum.

Sponsored by the Red Oak Express and KCSI, between opening and closing statements, all eight candidates fielded questions prepared by moderators Gregory Orear and Jerry Dietz as well as a couple submitted by the audience.

The first question dealt with one of the current council’s more controversial decisions: providing $56,000 in funding to the Montgomery County Family YMCA.

While Russell Williams (at-large candidate) said he would have liked to seen some of the funding sent to the schools, Steve Fenn (Ward 3), John Haidsiak (Ward 1), Denny Jones (at-large) and Scott Keith (Ward 1) all disagreed with the council’s decision, citing the frequent budget constraints. Haidsiak was the only opposing candidate to suggest another funding choice.

“We better be looking at our first line of defense in this community rather than just throwing the money out for whatever,” he said. “Our first line of defense is law enforcement. Without them, we are in deep trouble.”

Larry Barnett (Ward 3), Jeanice Lester (at-large) and Roger Waggener (Ward 1), who is running for re-election, supported the funding this year and said he would again in the future.

“I was one of the councilmen who voted to give $56,000 because I saw the list of items our Y provided for our youth,” Waggener said. “They talk about spending more on police and stuff like that, well, going to the Y and giving kids something to do keeps the kids off the streets and puts their mind on something else.”

The downtown revitilization plan drew equally stark opnions.

“I like the idea of downtown beautification, but I don’t like the idea of spending all the money to do it,” Fenn said. “I think the money already spent could have been spent in a more proactive way towards doing something. I don’t think the way we have gone about it so far is correct.”

Fenn said instead of paying one engineer to design it, the City should solicit designs from contractors, whom he believes would do it for free.

“Then we come in and see the big picture,” he said. “We might have 10 contractors come in and give us an idea, instead of just one.”
Haidsiak agreed.

“I agree there needs to be some improvements downtown, but I don’t feel we need to stick a feather in someone’s hat for a multi-million dollar project we may not need,” he said. “We need to make sure we have the funds available to do it.”

Barnett, who was appointed earlier this year to fill the remainder of Ivan Criag’s term as the at-large representative, is running for the third ward seat. He not only voice support for the plan, but challenged its critics.

“Be careful about using multi-million dollar project terms. We don’t know what it’s going to cost yet, that’s the purpose of the study. We’re not sure how we can fund it, that’s the purpose of the study,” he said. “Unless you look at something, how do you know what its going to cost or if you can do it or not. So let’s be careful about condemning a project before we know more about it.”

Lester said the City needed to be proactive in attracting business.

“I do see things are deteorating a little bit, especially around the square. The point is, I love Red Oak and I think Red Oak is great, but just because I say so, doesn’t mean the average person who comes here is going to think so either,” she said. “We have to offer something unique for the people to come and shop and bring businesses here.”

And while most of the candidates voiced support for the recreation trails, Fenn again challenged the feasibility of the project.

“I think the dollar amounts they are spending to do it are on the excessive side,” he said. “It’s a great idea, but it needs to be looked at a little better.”

Haidsiak, Waggener, Keith and Jones all mentioned city wide cleanups as components of beautifying Red Oak, while Williams targeted dilapidated houses.

“We need to go after some of these houses around town that are deteoriating that no one has lived in for years,” he said. “That would be a good start.”

Williams also stated he believes the current Council did more harm than good to the economic climate when it passed the sign ordinance.

“I don’t think the whole city sign ordinance was a good idea,” he said. “That is probably driving business away from the town. It would be a good start to just get rid of that ordinance.”

Kieth said he would like to see the City intensify its job recruitment efforts.

“I think they need to be more aggressive on what they are bringing back in,” he said. “We lost a lot of jobs in the last few years and they are getting jobs back in, but its not near enough to replace what we lost, so a little more aggressive would be a good idea.”

All the candidates agreed on the need to reinstitute a 5 or 10-year street plan, although Waggener defended the City’s recent direction on street projects.

“We have replaced two major bridges in town since then, Nuckols Street and Coolbaugh Street which is quite expensive,” he said. “But the council has talked about it recently and will get back to it.”

Haidsiak, who spent 10 years working in the street department, stated the streets are in worse condition than what meets the eye.

“Having worked on the street department, I found out that what looked like a good street was really just a band aid,” he said. “You look at some of these streets they asphalted and repatched what should have been 2-3 inches of asphalt wound up being a half to three-quarters of an inch. No wonder it wore out so fast.”

The Red Oak Express

222 E. Coolbaugh St.
P.O. Box 377
Red Oak, IA 51566
Phone: 712-623-2566 Fax: 712-623-2568

Comment Here