Costs are more for sanitation services

Dear Editor,

As one of the owners of Batten Sanitation Service, Inc., I feel compelled to write this as an answer to the article by Jennifer Horner.
She is under the assumption mandatory trash service for the city of

Red Oak would cost citizens less and they would receive more service.
She states she has done extensive research and compares garbage service with water and electricity, which I find to not be comparable.
There are several things in her article I’d like to address.

Batten Sanitation Service, Inc., is paid by the city to handle recycling. We have paid a considerable amount for the containers and recently purchased a third.

We haul those containers to the Page County Landfill and pay them to take the recyclables. The amount of trips we make has more than doubled since we were able to include cardboard.

We did not ask the city for an increase in our contract price for 12 years. With the increase in trips, cost of fuel and purchasing one more container, we did ask for a slight increase in 2011. Basically, that increase covered the purchasing of the third container.

We did not want the city to feel they needed to increase the amount they are charging on the water bill for recycling. We are pro recycling and encourage our customers to recycle.

The article compared Red Oak garbage service to what is provide in the City of Spencer.

Spencer’s population is almost double Red Oak’s. Yes, Spencer has mandatory service and curbside recycling for $13 a month. But the service is provided by the City and not a private company.

The City of Spencer purchased a privately owned company in 1988 and has provided the service since that time. Regular trash is hauled to a transfer station in town and their tonnage fee is $47.96 per ton.
I just received notice as of Sept. 15, our tonnage fee will increase $9.90 per ton, making it more than $20 per ton higher than Spencer’s.

In Spencer, recyclables (minus cardboard) are co-mingled and taken to a company that does not charge to take them. The cardboard is hauled separately to another company that pays the city for the cardboard.

There is nowhere in Southwest Iowa or within 100 miles that can sort co-mingled recyclables. To have trucks set up to haul separated recyclables and hiring additional employees would be at a considerable cost to the hauler.

As for regular trash pickup, Spencer residences are allowed 40 gallons, not to exceed 50 pounds per week. Anything over that requires you pre-purchase a sticker. Red Oak residents are allowed 99 gallons of trash, not to exceed 150 pounds per week.

To compare either services or costs between the two cities is like comparing an apple to an orange.

Respectfully submitted,

Mary Jane Walker

Presdient, Batten Sanitation Service, Inc.

The Red Oak Express

222 E. Coolbaugh St.
P.O. Box 377
Red Oak, IA 51566
Phone: 712-623-2566 Fax: 712-623-2568

Comment Here