Consultant trying to devise plan for Association
Frank Spillers came to Red Oak Tuesday to facilitate a meeting between the Chamber and Industry Association board and its investors to gather information regarding the organization’s direction.
While he received a lot of input, what remains to be seen is if he can use that information to form a definitive plan in the wake of the resignation of the Association’s executive director.
Darrell Steven Carlyle resigned June 11 amidst complaints from board members and investors that he wasn’t performing his duties as executive director of the group that formed about three years ago when the Chamber and Industry Association merged.
After the resignation, the board decided to meet with investors to discuss what direction the organization should be headed and what the role of the executive director should be.
At last week’s meeting, which included 10 of the 13 board members and about 15 investors, one thing was agreed upon: the organization’s first priority should be creating jobs.
Beyond that, opinions on how to achieve that goal and what exactly the new director should and should not be doing were varied, to say the least.
A majority of those who spoke about the role of the new director agreed Carlyle was the wrong person for the job. The most poignant criticisms came from members of the contact committee, which includes George Maher, Jim Sifford, Ken Rech, Brad Wright and Kristie Konz. That committee, one of eight in the Association, is charged with recruiting industry and Wright stated Carlyle was not assertive enough.
“The director needs to be a promoter. He needs to be a leader,” Wright said. “From the contact committee aspect, what we had was a secretary as our past director. That’s not what we need from a contact committee aspect, that’s not what we need from an economic development aspect. We need a leader.”
While Maher advocated the new director focuses on chamber-related activities and promoting the town, while leaving the industry recruitment to thecontact committee, Sifford believed the position could be filled on a part-time basis.
Sifford, who chairs the contact committee, also believes that committee should have “some authority” over the director, whom he also believes needs to have Red Oak ties.
“I don’t think there is a ton of things wrong with the Chamber. I think we had a director who wasn’t suited for the job,” he said. “I don’t want to lose the focus that if we had a different exec to begin with we may not be here and this may be a whole different situation. I don’t want to see a ton of things changed just because the man wasn’t doing his job.”
Dave Jennings, who served as the Association’s first president, held himself personally responsible for Carlyle’s failure, adding the board would need to make sure a similar mistake wasn’t repeated.
“I feel very embarrassed,” he said. “I was part of the committee and head of the new organization and I didn’t step up and say you aren’t doing the job. We have to as a board get tough and say you aren’t doing the job and we are going to find someone else.”
Ann Carder said it’s important for the board to agree upon their expectations and communicate them clearly.
“The reason we had difficulty with our executive … was the fact we didn’t clearly define what our expectations were,” she said. “We had expectations, but when they weren’t met, we said ‘what the heck, he should have been at that event’ and all those criticisms after the fact. We need to be clear what we expect.
“We can’t criticize someone if we didn’t give them clearer expectations up front.”
Jennings agreed the concept of merging the two groups remains a good idea, but questioned its implementation.
“We brought two organizations to make one. To this very day, it’s the chamber and something else. We never, ever joined as one,” he said.
“I still think we are headed in the right direction. {But} we can’t be the Chamber and something else. The Chamber is no more, it is gone. There’s the Chamber and Industrial Association. If we get the appropriate people to direct the organization, we can make this work.”
Spillers, who was joined at the meeting by his wife Kimberly, is the co-owner of the Global Horizons consulting company. He has worked as a development director for the Cass/Atlantic Development Corporation; executive director of the Iowa Rural Development Council; and most recently, owned the Atlantic Maid-Rite Sandwich Shoppe. Spillers will present his proposal to the Board at its monthly meeting Tuesday at 11:30 a.m. at the Red Oak Country Club.
