A closer look at Christmas

Was it my imagination, or did the anti-Christ in Christmas movement pick up more steam than usual this past season? We noted considerable activity from both sides; in the Detroit suburb of Warren, the County Road Commission reacted to a letter from the Freedom from Religion Foundation and ordered the removal of a prominently placed nativity scene. A federal appeals court in Philadelphia upheld a New Jersey school district’s ban on songs that contain any reference to Christ. The judges noted that such songs have been common since the founding of our nation, but that “times have changed.” Christmas trees in state capitols are officially “Holiday trees.” In Amelia, Ohio, a scheduled Christmas Parade was on-again, off-again due to a controversy regarding whether it could be called a “Christmas” parade. An organization known as “Liberty Counsel” has put out a list of retailers that are either “naughty or nice,” depending largely on how they word their holiday greetings. In California a teacher named Merry Hyatt, expressing dismay that no traditional carols are allowed in public schools, is circulating a petition calling for a ballot initiative that would require them. On November 3rd the Catholic League President, Bill Donohue, issued a news release citing numerous examples of what he called the “War on Christmas.”

An organization named Americans United for the Separation of Church and State (AU) argues that the religious right has “stolen” Christmas. The religious right responds that they couldn’t steal Christmas; it was a gift. The AU has a website soliciting reports of possible violations of church/state separation and a battery of lawyers prepared to set things straight. A contrarian view is taken by the “Alliance Defense Fund (ADF),” which also has a bevy of lawyers at their disposal.

AU believes religious freedom can only exist when strictly separated from the government. ADF takes the position that freedom of religion means the freedom to pray and sing religious songs, even in schools and government buildings.

In September a group of Orthodox, Catholic and Evangelical religious leaders met in New York and produced what they call the “Manhattan Agreement.” The agreement goes far beyond Christmas, citing not just religious freedom, but the sanctity of human life and belief in marriage as a union between one man and one woman. The ADF signed on shortly before Christmas and is giving the document more publicity than it might otherwise have gotten.

What puzzles me is why the AU or a similar group fails to take action against our federal and state governments for declaring Christmas a holiday? If the government crosses the line in calling a Christmas tree what it is, then surely government goes much too far in designating the day a holiday in the first place.

One side or the other is going to eventually take all the marbles in this one, and I’d bet one day Christmas will be replaced by a holiday of another name.

Roy Marshall is a local historian. E-mail him at news@redoakexpress.com.

The Red Oak Express

222 E. Coolbaugh St.
P.O. Box 377
Red Oak, IA 51566
Phone: 712-623-2566 Fax: 712-623-2568

Comment Here