Climate predictions not panning out?
Dear Editor:
Recently I was perusing through one of my favorite news aggregator sites and saw reference to China burning one billion more tons of coal than previously reported. The original report was from a New York Times article, so I went to the article and read it. It turns out China had reported it produced one billion tons more carbon dioxide per year from burning coal than previously reported. The Times article also stated this is an increase of 17 percent over their previously reported numbers. It also said the number was equivalent to about 70 percent of the U.S. annual carbon dioxide output from burning coal.
For seven years, we have been told that the science on global warming or climate change is settled and that carbon dioxide is the culprit that is going to destroy our world if we don’t stop producing it. This settled science is based on the greenhouse effect on climate change models that were developed in 1981 as well as, I’m sure, some modifications of those models. Now, I am no climate-change expert nor am I knowledgeable enough in the albedo of the earth, flux of solar radiation and the Stefan-Blotzmann constant, all components of the models, to contest the science, so I have to depend on plain English information I can read and actual events to draw my own conclusions from the differing opinions.
Another critical component of these models is the emitted carbon dioxide, and it seems to me that a 17 percent increase by the largest producer of carbon dioxide would significantly affect the outcome of the models and the real world. I would assume this effect would be an acceleration of the forecasted climate change, but from what I can find, the results have come up short of the predictions.
One of the predictions, repeated as recently as 2009 by Secretary of State John Kerry, was that the arctic would be ice-free by 2014 or 2015. According to the National Snow & Ice Data Center, which is supported by NASA, the 2015 measurement was 2.98 million square miles of arctic ice, down 460,000 square miles from the 1981 measurement but up 367,000 square miles from the record low set in 2007. I would say that the arctic is a little ways from being ice free.
Another easily visualized prediction was that the sea level would rise by 15-20 feet in the 100 years after 1981. It has been 34 years since the models predicted this, I believe adequate time to see visual results of sea-level rise, has passed, yet not a single low-lying city has been flooded and most suspicious to me is there is no talk of major new seawall construction. With cities like Boston, New York, Miami, Mobile and New Orleans all within the predicted rise, wouldn’t you think there would be some talk of building protective dikes? Around 5.5 million people live in Miami-Dade County, Florida at an elevation of six feet or less, yet neither the county nor state is making any attempt to protect their people from the sea-level rise.
What I find most curious is the big move to save us from ourselves is to force our power plants to switch from coal to natural gas, a move that, from what I read, will reduce the temperature by about 0.03 degrees Celsius (I have seen predictions from 0.01 to 0.05) by the year 2050. Is .03 of a degree really going to save us?
One 1981 prediction about carbon dioxide that has come true; Dr. Sherwood Idso predicted the increase in carbon dioxide “would have little effect except to increase agricultural productivity by 20-50 percent.”
For the record, I am not a climate change denier; we have four and a half billion years of history to prove it exists, but I am a “settled science” skeptic. A great website with lots of scientific data is co2science.org.
Doug Simpson
Red Oak
