City pay raises coming at a bad time
At last week’s City Council meeting, Larry Brandstetter got that deer-in-the-headlights look when the budget discussion turned to water and sewer rates.
Due to a lack of increases for several years, the city is jumping both rates by 10 percent under the new proposed budget. The increase, which would take affect in July, prompted Brandstetter to remark “we are going to pay the price,” presumably referring to the large increase necessitated by the lack of one for quite a while.
After researching the past 10 years of newspapers for the Express’ ongoing Decade in Review, which starts today, I would have wholeheartedly agreed with Councilman Brandstetter five years ago.
Back then, with controversy upon controversy sprung out of the board of supervisors, assessors and auditors office, sheriff’s department, city council and police departments, the Express’ editorial page was overflowing with outraged citizen comments.
Now, either the topics aren’t nearly as controversial, or the public has become much more accepting, as I really don’t think even a double digit hike in water rates will get too many people riled up; certainly not enough for the Council to be concerned.
And quite frankly, the increases are needed, as steep as they may be. Costs have increased for everything, ranging from chemicals to labor, and those costs have to be passed along to the consumer.
But what is concerning about this budget, and what should get the public riled up, is those aforementioned labor costs.
Despite the struggling economy, in which Montgomery County has one of the highest unemployment rates in the state near 10 percent, this budget allow for across the board pay raises for city employees, ranging from 2.5 to 5 percent.
While the current economic climate is reason enough to be concerned with this, compounding the issue is a sharp decline in revenue.
Compared to just two years ago, the city is projected to collect $1.2 million less in revenue, while spending nearly $140,000 more in payroll.
To put that in perspective, 21 percent of all revenue two years ago was expended on labor. Under the new budget, 25 percent of revenue will go toward payroll.
That’s a big jump. And what that means, is with less money coming in, and more going out for labor costs, the city will be spending less money elsewhere.
Councilman Brandstetter wanted to point out that the city’s expenses are down nearly $100,000 from last year, from $4.4 to $4.3 million, which is true. However, those savings weren’t realized in payroll, which is up two percent from that same budget.
It is easy to point fingers and criticize government when they dole out pay raises to employees. It’s an easy target because they are spending tax dollars, our tax dollars.
And I’m not arguing that city employees don’t deserve the raises. But in an economy where nearly 1 out of every 10 Montgomery County residents don’t have a job, where water and sewer rates are increasing 10 percent, and revenues are down 13 percent from just two years ago, I would argue this probably isn’t the best time for those raises.
A lot of companies are forcing furlough days, layoffs, and early retirements on employees. A one-year pay freeze for city employees doesn’t seem that outlandish.
So if Brandstetter is right, and the Council does “pay the price,” for the water/sewer rate increases, I’d argue those pay raises will make that price much higher.
Gregory Orear is the General Manager/Editor of the Red Oak Express. He can be emailed at publisher@redoakexpress.com.
