Bucking the trend
RED OAK — Every year since 1996, the number of cesarean deliveries has steadily risen in the United States.
Starting around 20 percent 15 years ago, the rate increased every year, topping out at a national record 32.9 percent in 2009, according to a study published by the National Vital Statistics Report.
And Iowa’s numbers reflect the national trend, growing to a record 30.2 percent in 2009.
But a very different story is emerging from Montgomery County’s hospital, where three doctors are embracing the traditional, and healthier, vaginal birth option.
While state and national cesarean rates have been climbing, MCMH’s rate over the past three years has fluctuated from a low of 15.2 percent in 2008, to a high of 22.1 percent (the seventh lowest in the state) in 2009.
After a 20 percent rate in 2010, the number of cesarean births through March of 2011 is 3 out of 17, or 18 percent.
Dr. Christopher Johnson, who delivers babies at MCMH along with Dr. William Butz and Dr. Brian Crouse, said a mother’s first birth experience is the most important, as it will determine if future children are delivered naturally or via cesarean.
“That first c-section rate is what matters so much,” he said.
In those primary deliveries, Dr. Johnson delivered 132 of 135 babies naturally from 2008-2010.
“The really great thing is if you can maintain this sort of rate, people will come back four their second, third, and fourth child, and the labor becomes much easier, and mothers have push much less and are recovering much faster,” he said.
Dr. Butz said there are reasons for a good reasons to conduct a cesarean birth, but it should never be the first option.
You want to do a c-section when you have an infant in distress. Occasionally, a c-section is done when the mom is in stress or in an emergency situation, but a majority of the time, it’s because the infant is in trouble,” he said. ”There are areas of the nation where doctors are offering c-sections over vaginal births. But the reason you don’t do that, is cesarean delivery carries a higher risk to the mother with bleeding, infection, and even death to the mom, and a higher risk to the baby.”
Johnson said beyond the short-term risks to the mother of infection, hemorrhage, and a longer recovery time, he said there are additional long-term complications as well, especially in regards to future pregnancies.
Specifically, Johnson said mothers who have undergone multiple cesareans are more likely to succumb to placenta accreta, in which the placenta attaches to the uterine wall. In addition to a ruptured uterine, mothers most likely will be faced with an emergency hysterectomy.
“The blood loss in those cases is massive,” Johnson said. “WE had one case six years ago where we had to do a hysterectomy after delivery, which was the mother’s fifth c-section. We had to give her six units and ran out of her blood type, but fortunately, we are able to stop the bleeding before she needed more.”
MCMH Chief Nurse Executive Joanne Nathem said the facility’s low c-section rate is a direct reflection on the doctors involved.
“At one time, c-sections were more prevalent because they were more convenient, as were inductions. Our physicians are more concerned though with the overall health of the mother and baby,” Nathem said.
Butz said after a mother delivers a child via cesarean, the likelihood of a vaginal birth is greatly reduced, and is rarely done at the Red Oak hospital.
“If you offer labor and cesarean delivery, you need to have everyone here and available in case you don need to go with a cesarean,” he said. “The trend is to go back towards offering labor first, and do it with a select few. An emergency cesarean delivery has a lot more risk than a routine one.”
Regarding the infant, Dr. Butz said there is increased risk of respiratory complications.
“Infants are not as vigorous because of the lack of stress they are under, and as a result, there is a higher risk of reccessitation.”
With the undisputed increase risk to mother and child, in addition to the higher costs associated with the surgical method of delivering birth, Johnson theorizes a reason for it.
“Some of my colleagues around the country are practicing defensive medicine in fear or malpractice lawsuits and when they see fetal distress, they quickly decided to perform the c-section,” he said, adding MCMH’s low cesarean rate is the facility’s greatest unknown secret.
But sometimes, Johnson believes it is for an even more callous reason.
“It comes down to how much dedication do you have as a doctor,” Johnson said. “Nobody in this hospital is doing 5 o-clock c-sections where the doctor is saying ‘oops, it’s 5 p.m. and I want to go home and the mother is no advancing fast enough.’”
