Auditor’s office in violation of state election law
The Montgomery County Auditor’s office is in violation of state election laws regarding the retention of voter registration records.
Auditor Stephanie Burke recommended increasing the currently vacant election deputy position from 20 budgeted hours to 30 per week to remedy the problem. The Montgomery County Board of Supervisors voted 3-2 against Burke’s recommendation due to financial concerns.
The auditor’s office currently has three full time employees who are all certified as election administrators through the Secretary of State. Last year, the office also had a part-time, 20 hour per week employee who left, and the position remains vacant.
According to Burke, even with three and a half employees, they would lack enough manpower to keep up with voter registration records, including removing registrants who have moved away or who are deceased.
Aside from record retention, Burke said the election deputy would also be a valuable resource during an election, sorting the increasing number of absentee ballots and staying up to date on other election laws.
“We follow all the election laws at the time someone registers and during the election itself and we do so with integrity,” Burke said. “[Increasing the budgeted number of hours] is a need not a want. This is my job, and I need to find a way to do what needs to be done now. It’s hard for someone outside to understand all the work that needs to be done in this office, but it’s year-round.”
Burke suggested amending the county’s current budget, which ends June 30, to add $11,500 for the 10 extra hours. The 30-hour position for the 2014-15 fiscal year would cost the county about $31,500 plus almost $14,000 in benefits. Whereas at 20 hours, the county would pay up to $20,600 annually for the position without benefits.
Supervisor Donna Robinson voted against Burke’s recommendation, stating it was not fiscally responsible. Supervisors Karen Blue and Randy Tye also voted against the increased hours.
“I think it’s important we get the work done and become compliant with the state election laws, but it’s also important to do so within our budgetary limits,” Robinson said. “It will take time, but I have confidence in that office and in the auditor that it can be done with what’s been allotted.”
Board Chairman Bryant Amos was not so confident.
“There will be a cost, but keeping up with records is what we have to do,” Amos said. “With the current staff, they just can’t keep up. There’s no other way to get it done. I trust the auditor and how she runs the department. They know what they need.”
Along with Amos, Supervisor Steve Ratcliff voted in favor of Burke’s recommendation.
According to Burke, if the budgeted hours are not increased the county will pay for the needed work in overtime, which is currently maxed out for the department.
“I do understand the importance of being fiscally responsible, but we are deficient in some areas,” Burke said. “We are going to have to pay for it one way or another so I’d rather have someone qualified come in.”
Whoever fills the position, whether at 20 or 30 hours, would ideally have some experience in elections and would become certified through the state as an election administrator, a process that is not available for two years.
“To have someone at only 20 hours and to go to the expense of having them certified and not give them benefits, I question how long can we keep a quality employee,” Amos said. “It would put us right back where we are now.”
Being in violation of the law is not the only concern, though, according to Burke.
The Department of Criminal Investigation (DCI) has been in the neighboring counties of Page and Pottawattamie checking into voter fraud and voter registration issues, according to Burke. And without warning, she said they could show up at the Montgomery County Auditor’s Office.
“If and when they are going to come, I don’t know,” Burke said. “I really don’t know what will happen, but it looks bad for Montgomery County.”
Both Amos and Robinson said they too are concerned about a potential criminal investigation.
“It’s a possibility, but I think that office is doing a lot of things really well and it’s a risk we just have to take,” Robinson said. “I’m sure there are a lot of other larger counties doing things wrong that should be looked into first, but it’s always a concern.”
For Amos, a DCI investigation is a worry he’s just hoping won’t come to fruition.
“This isn’t going to go away,” Amos said. “This is an injustice to our auditor. She’s saying she can’t do it; we should support that.”
Amos said the suggestion of increasing the hours for the election deputy position will come up again, likely after the first of the year when the board begins planning the next budget.
“It has to come up again,” Amos said. “I don’t know if it will pass, but I ask the supervisors who voted against it, ‘what’s the alternative?’ Eventually we’ll pay for it with enough overtime and the training involved.”
