10 Years in Prison
RED OAK — An Essex teenager was sentenced to 10 years in prison for her part in a November 2010 car wreck that killed two children.
Karli Jo Brown, 19, received two concurrent 10-year sentences for the two counts of vehicular homicide she pleaded guilty to in September.
The charges stemmed from a Nov. 28 accident in which Brown was passing in a no-passing zone and struck a car driven by Nina McNeese head-on, south of Red Oak on Highway 48. McNeese’s two sons, Maliki, 5, and Alex, 4, were killed in the accident.
“There is nothing I could do that would bring these two young men back,” District Judge James Heckerman said before sentencing Brown. “But the bottom line is, there are two dead boys because of the actions of this defendant … and that requires some kind of punishment.”
Brown’s sentencing followed tear-filled statements issued by McNeese, her mother and cousin.
“My babies don’t get to graduate. I don’t get to see a wedding or a prom,” McNeese said in the courtroom, accompanied by about 12 family members and friends. “It was her choice to make those decisions and it was her who caused that wreck … I understand she was young, but at 18, you know the rules.”
McNeese’s mother, Julia Herold, and her husband Roy recently purchased a camper to spend more time with her grandsons.
“We have no life now. We have nothing left. They were all I had as grandchildren,” she said. “We had two boys there in the same casket. I shouldn’t have had to do that. They were just babies.”
Karli’s mother, Kathy testified on her daughter’s behalf, tearfully stating how difficult the accident has been on her family as well.
“I’m not sure words can express the sympathy and regret over what happened,” she said. “If we could go make it all not happen, we would … I can’t ask for forgiveness, because I know I can’t expect that. But I will pray for you everyday.”
Karli, who appeared in court in a wheelchair due to ongoing medical issues surrounding a broken ankle suffered in the wreck, said she wasn’t in a hurry at the time or trying to be careless.
“I want to say that there is no excuse for what happened,” she said. “I didn’t try to make excuse, no matter when people tell me it’s not my fault … but I want to tell the whole truth that I thought I was in a passing zone. It’s stupid, but I really did.”
She also said when she started to pass, the second car sped up.
“I want people to know that,” she added. “But I would give my life for those boys in a minute. I don’t care. It hurts so much everyday. Knowing how much I hurt, I can’t imagine how much you hurt.”
Her attorney, Seth Baldwin, argued for a deferred judgment and no prison time.
“She made a stupid mistake. That stupid mistake resulted in the death of two young children and nothing can change that,” he said. “This is something that is going to haunt her for the rest of her life and there is nothing the state of Iowa can do for punishment that will match what she has gone through and will go through.”
After the sentencing, Brown said while she was glad she had the chance to apologize to McNeese, she doubted it was very effective.
“It’s not going to change anything. No matter what I say, it’s not going to help,” she said.
She also disputed official reports she was texting while driving.
“Those stories are wrong,” she said. “I was texting him (her boyfriend, Zach Cox) before. But I didn’t say anything about that, because it is wrong to text and drive.”
After the sentencing, McNeese said she has shared her story with students at Shenandoah high school, where she graduated, to warn them about the dangers of texting while driving.
She is also scheduled to talk to students in Sidney, Nebraska City and Plattsmouth. McNeese is also enrolled in college at Northwest Missouri State University in Maryville, and will be studying sociology corrections with a minor in criminal justice.
Brown was turned over to the custody of the Montgomery County Sheriff’s Department, and will be transferred to the Adams County jail in Corning.
Brown’s mother said the sentencing didn’t really surprise her.
“After the year we had, we were expecting anything,” she said. “Hopefully, this will bring some closure and let people start the healing process.”
She said they do plan on appealing the judge’s sentence.
Regardless of what happens in the appeal process, McNeese wanted the judge to know she will always try to stand up for her children.
“I want my children to know I fought for them.”
